Category: Essays, Letters & Speeches

Dionysius of Halicarnassus On Literary Composition Being the Greek Text of the De Compositione Verborum

If there were any doubt that the Greek accent was an affair of pitch rather than of stress, the eleventh chapter of this treatise would go far to remove it. It is clear that Dionysius describes the difference between the acute and the grave accent as a variation of pitch, and...

Chapters

40. c. 19) τοῦ ἤχου would be more common than σπανίζειν τὸν ἦχον:

(4) σπαδονισμοὺς τῶν ἤχων (‘impediments to sound,’ ‘arrested sounds’) occurs, without variant, in _de Demosth._ c. 40, and is adopted by U.-R. as well as by other editors; (5) t...

41. xiv. 439-42), an endeavour is made to view the literary life of

[Footnote 74: Among the shorter fragments preserved by him are one of Bacchylides (in c. 25), and another from the _Telephus_ of Euripides (in c. 26). Two lines of the _Danaë_ a...

32. CHAPTER XXV

Now that I have finished this part of the subject, I think you must be eager for information on the next point—how unmetrical language is made to resemble a beautiful poem or ly...

33. CHAPTER XXVI

Concerning melodious metrical composition which bears a close affinity to prose, my views are of the following kind. The prime factor here too, just as in the case of poetical p...

1. Part i. (1906), p. 45, there is a short “Discourse on Music” which the

If there were any doubt that the Greek accent was an affair of pitch rather than of stress, the eleventh chapter of this treatise would go far to remove it. It is clear that Dio...

29. i. 1), where the word in each case is said to end in ι, have led

some persons to suppose that Dionysius pronounced οι and αι as real diphthongs of two vowels ending in ι. We know, however, that at this time αι was a single vowel ε prolonged,...

18. CHAPTER XIV

1 ἃ R: ἃς libri 3 πρώτων F: πρω[**TN: τ written above ω of πρω] P: πρῶτον RMVs 4 τελευταῖα P: τελευταῖον R: τελευταῖαν FVs: τελευταίαν M 9 μὴ φωνηέντων REFM: μὲν φωνηέντων PR^b:...

7. CHAPTER IV

To show yet more conclusively the great force wielded by the faculty of composition both in poetry and prose, I will quote some passages which are universally regarded as fine,...

30. CHAPTER XXIII

1 ἓν EPM: om. FV 5 κεκινῆσθαι EF: κ[αὶ] κινῆσθαι cum rasura P: καὶ κινεῖσθαι MV 6 φέρεσθαι EFM: φέρεσθαι καὶ PV || τῶν ἑτέρων PMV: τῶν θατέρων F: θατέρων E || καὶ FMV: om. P ||...

23. CHAPTER XVIII

The reason why I have been led to make these preliminary remarks (for certainly it was no part of my design to touch without due cause on metrical and rhythmical questions, but...

15. CHAPTER XI

Among the sources of charm and beauty in style there are, I conceive, four which are paramount and essential,—melody, rhythm, variety, and the appropriateness demanded by these...

34. c. 11 ἐὰν δὲ μηδεμίαν ἡδονὴν μηδὲ ἀφροδίτην ὁ τῆς λέξεως

=ἄφωνος.= =138= 13, =140= 3, =146= 5, =148= 11, 20, =220= 10. _Voiceless_, _mute_. Lat. _vocis expers_, _mutus_. From the standpoint of the modern science of phonetics, in which...

6. i. 50, πρωΐας ἔτι οὔσης ὀλίγον τινὰ ἐσθίομεν ἄρτον καὶ ἄκρατον οἶνον

9. The charm of a simple scene, simply but beautifully described, is seen in Virg. _Ecl._ vii. 1-15; _Georg._ ii. 385-9; _Aen._ v. 328-30, 357-60. (The Latin illustrations, here...

26. CHAPTER XX

It still remains for me to speak about appropriateness. All the other ornaments of speech must be associated with what is appropriate; indeed, if any other quality whatever fail...

35. c. 47 ὥσπερ οἴονταί τινες καὶ καλοῦσι τὸν οὕτως κατασκευασθέντα

=ἦθος.= =88= 12, =160= 17, =212= 11. _Character_. Lat. _mos_, _indoles_. Cp. Demetr. p. 284, D.H. p. 193. See Jebb’s _Attic Orators_ i. 30, 31 for _pathos_ and _ethos_ in Antiph...

39. c. 24 ταῦτα μὲν δὴ παραγγέλλουσι ποιεῖν οἱ τεχνογράφοι), and

=παράδειγμα.= =92= 5, =136= 2, =152= 3, =214= 6, =232= 23, =240= 24, etc. _Instance._ Lat. _exemplum_. τὰ παραδείγματα is often used of appropriate (perhaps customary, or stock)...

19. CHAPTER XV

Such is the number of the letters, and such are their properties. From them are formed the so-called _syllables_. Of these syllables, those are long which contain long vowels or...

28. CHAPTER XXII

The characteristic feature of the austere arrangement is this:—It requires that the words should be like columns firmly planted and placed in strong positions, so that each word...

22. CHAPTER XVII

I have mentioned that rhythm contributes in no small degree to dignified and impressive composition; and I will treat of this point also. Let no one suppose that rhythm and metr...

20. CHAPTER XVI

The poets and prose-writers themselves, then, with their eye on each object in turn, frame—as I said—words which seem made for, and are pictures of, the things they connote. But...

3. CHAPTER I

To you, Rufus Metilius, whose worthy father is my most honoured friend, “I also offer this gift, dear child,”[85] as Helen, in Homer, says while entertaining Telemachus. To-day...

2. c. 14 only of the treatise, but the quotation enabled Usener to show

that the text of F agreed in the main with that of the _Rhetor_ and of the Epitome. The result was to enhance greatly the authority of F, with which earlier editors had merely a...

16. CHAPTER XII

It is not in the nature of all the words in a sentence to affect the ear in the same way, any more than all visible objects produce the same impression on the sense of sight, th...

9. CHAPTER VI

My view is that the science of composition has three functions. The first is that of observing the combinations which are naturally adapted to produce a beautiful and agreeable...

25. CHAPTER XIX

The third cause of beautiful arrangement that was to be examined is variety. I do not mean the change from the better to the worse (that would be too foolish), nor yet that from...

8. CHAPTER V

Well, my notion was that we ought to follow mother nature to the utmost, and to link together the parts of speech according to her promptings. For example, I thought I must plac...

24. ii. 38 καὶ αὐτὴν (Τάρπειαν) ἔρως εἰσέρχεται τῶν ψαλίων, ἃ περὶ τοῖς

ἀριστεροῖς βραχίοσιν ἐφόρουν (οἱ Σαβῖνοι), καὶ τῶν δακτυλίων.—Probably here a large curb-chain is meant, rather than a cheek-ring, which would be too small. So Curtius iv. 6. 29...

31. CHAPTER XXIV

The third kind of composition is the mean between the two already mentioned. I call it _harmoniously blended_ for lack of a proper and better name. It has no form peculiar to it...

13. CHAPTER IX

I think I can in a very few words show that some clauses admit changes which take the form now of additions not necessary to the sense, now of curtailments rendering the sense i...

36. c. 48 ἔν τε ταῖς μεταβολαῖς τοτὲ μὲν τὸ ἀρχαιοπρεπὲς καὶ

=μέλος.= =204= 3, _limb_: =122= 24, =126= 21 (_bis_), =194= 7, 13, _tune_, _melody_: =120= 18, =122= 11, =130= 4, 11, _melodious effect_, _tunefulness_: =92= 22, =120= 26, =126=...

4. CHAPTER II

_Composition_ is, as the very name indicates, a certain arrangement of the parts of speech, or elements of diction, as some call them. These were reckoned as three only by Theod...

21. iii. 3 (1406 a) ἐν μὲν γὰρ ποιήσει πρέπει γάλα λευκὸν εἰπεῖν, ἐν δὲ

The minute variations in word-order between F and P are not usually given in the critical footnotes. But the fact that P places (here and in =164= 17) the verb at the end of the...

11. CHAPTER VII

The foregoing, then, is one branch of the art of composition which requires consideration: namely, that which relates to the primary parts and elements of speech. But there is a...

27. CHAPTER XXI

I assert without any hesitation that there are many specific differences of composition, and that they cannot be brought into a comprehensive view or within a precise enumeratio...

12. CHAPTER VIII

The complete utterance of our thoughts takes more than one form. We throw them at one time into the shape of an assertion, at another into that of an inquiry, or a prayer, or a...

14. CHAPTER X

Now that I have laid down these broad outlines, the next step will be to state what should be the aims kept in view by the man who wishes to compose well, and by what methods hi...

37. c. 27 ἀντίθετον μὲν οὖν ἐστι τὸ ἐναντίαν τὴν ὀνομασίαν ἅμα

=ὀξύς.= =126= 5, 8, 10, =128= 6, 8. _Acute_ (accent), _high_ (pitch). Lat. _acutus_. So =ὀξύτης= =126= 14. Cp. s.v. βαρύς, p. 292 _supra_. In Aristot. _Poet._ c. 20 ὀξύτητι καὶ...

5. CHAPTER III

Every utterance, then, by which we express our thoughts is either in metre or not in metre. Whichever it be, it can, when aided by beautiful arrangement, attain beauty whether o...

17. CHAPTER XIII

So far, so good. But, if some one were to ask me in what way, and by attention to what principles, literary structure can be made beautiful, I should reply: In no other way, bel...

10. iii. 57 runs: καὶ οὔτε τῶν τότε ξυμμάχων ὠφελεῖ οὐδείς, ὑμεῖς τε, ὦ

discourse through the elisions. So again by using “ἐποίησε” (without the ν) in place of ἐποίησεν, and “ἔγραψε” in place of ἔγραψεν, and “ἀφαιρήσομαι” in place of ἀφαιρεθήσομαι,...

38. c. 8 (διάλεκτον) μεγαλοπρεπῆ λιτήν, περιττὴν ἀπέριττον,