Category: Philosophy & Ethics

Calvinistic Controversy Embracing a Sermon on Predestination and Election and Several Numbers, Formally Published in the Christian Advocate and Journal.

"Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year 1835, by B. Waugh and T. Mason, in the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the Southern District of New-York."

Chapters

17. Part 17

One erroneous assumption of this writer is, that "there is no free agency to do wrong, which is not adequate to do right." This writer seems to think this a self-evident proposi...

21. Part 21

2. It has been objected, that "since man never is what he ought to be until he is renewed and made holy, therefore any act short of that which either constitutes or implies rege...

20. Part 20

2. It may be said, and has sometimes been said, that this view of the subject involves a contradiction; that it is the same as to say, the man wills against his preference, or i...

13. Part 13

If there are embarrassments in the other case, and what theory of mind or matter has not its _inexplicables?_--these embarrassments are evidently of another kind; it is not the...

12. Part 12

Another argument against the Calvinistic doctrine of motives is, that it leads to materialism. The doctrine, it will be recollected, is this: When the mind is brought into conne...

2. Part 2

1. This doctrine of predestination makes God the author of sin. Some acknowledge this, and expressly assert, that God is the "_efficient_ cause" of sin. Others affirm it in fact...

15. Part 15

3. A third and intermediate theory on the subject of depravity and human responsibility is the one presented and advocated in the preceding number. This system is presented, in...

10. Part 10

2. Another reason for believing that this doctrine is what we have defined it to be, and involves in it the principles we have charged upon it, is drawn from the terms in which...

18. Part 18

_First Theory_.--The notion that the mind is entirely passive in this change, that is, that nothing is done by the subject of it, which is preparative or conditional, or in any...

1. Part 1

"Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year 1835, by B. Waugh and T. Mason, in the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the Southern District of New-York."

14. Part 14

3. On the ground of this doctrine, also, there would be some difficulty in accounting for the necessity of giving grace, in all cases, even to the elect. Why may not some of the...

5. Part 5

This sermon had been before the public almost two years before it received any notice, so far as the author is informed, from any of the advocates of predestination. After the t...

9. Part 9

"The first view is that which we understood to be advocated by Dr. Fisk, in the sermon we reviewed." The writer goes on farther to say that his objection to this is, "that it is...

19. Part 19

Indeed the very terms, _regeneration, born, birth_, &c, imply of themselves another and an efficient agent; and then to connect these with the Divine agency, as the Scriptures h...

6. Part 6

Since writing the above, I have seen an inquiry of a correspondent in one of the Calvinistic papers, in these words, "Why do our Calvinistic writers retain the words which seem...

8. Part 8

One modification of Calvinism remains to be mentioned. It is known by the name of the "New Divinity." The theological doctors connected with Yale college are the reputed authors...

16. Part 16

One thought more, with respect to this moral power, and I will pass on. The doctrine of Calvinism is, if I understand it, that God controls the natural power of men, by means of...

3. Part 3

1. The first class of passages that we will now examine, which are supposed to favour the idea of unconditional election, is those that speak of a predestination _unto_ holiness...

4. Part 4

3. The doctrine we oppose makes God partial and a respecter of persons; contrary to express and repeated declarations of Scripture. For it represents God as determining to save...

7. Part 7

But we are informed farther in this paragraph, that one great difficulty in complying with my condition is, that "Calvinists, as a class, are remarkable for thinking for themsel...

11. Part 11

It is certain that the moral standing of those angels and men whose states are now unalterably fixed, differs materially from their probationary state; and this difference rende...

22. Part 22

[6] A man was afflicted with the hydrophobia. When his paroxysms were coming on he was aware of it, and gave warning to his friends to be on their guard, that he might not injur...