CHAPTER XVII.
HANDWRITING AND EXPRESSION.
No work dealing with the study of handwriting would be complete unless it recognised that phase of it which touches on the delineation of character by an examination of the caligraphy.
That many valuable clues can be picked up by the expert who applies the principles on which the graphologist works is indisputable, nor is it necessary to accept all the theories claimed as reliable by those who practice this interesting branch of the art of writing-analysis.
There is no doubt that many persons have attained a remarkable degree of proficiency in deducing from the hand-gestures of an unknown person a very accurate estimate of his or her character, and this fact should prove that the principles of the art of graphology are based on scientific grounds, or at least that the rules on which the student works are regular and not, as some suggest, mere guess-work or coincidence.
The elder d'Israeli, in his fascinating work, the "Curiosities of Literature," devotes considerable space to the subject. Among other things, he says:--
"Assuredly nature would prompt every individual to have a distinct sort of writing, as she has given a peculiar countenance, a voice, and a manner. The flexibility of the muscles differs with every individual, and the hand will follow the direction of the thoughts, and the emotions and the habits of the writers.
"The phlegmatic will portray his words with signs of labour and deliberation, while the playful haste of the volatile will scarcely sketch them; the slovenly will blot and efface and scrawl, while the neat and orderly-minded will view themselves in the paper before their eyes. The merchant's clerk will not write like the lawyer or the poet. Even nations are distinguished by their writing; the vivacity and variableness of the Frenchman, and the delicacy and suppleness of the Italian, are perceptibly distinct from the slowness and strength of pen discoverable in the phlegmatic German, Dane, and Swede.
"When we are in grief we do not write as we should in joy. The elegant and correct mind, which has acquired the fortunate habit of a fixity of attention, will write with scarcely an erasure on the page, as Fenelon and Gibbon; while we find in Pope's manuscripts the perpetual struggle of correction, and the eager and rapid interlineations struck off in heat. Lavater's notion of handwriting is by no means chimerical; nor was General Paoli fanciful when he told Mr. Northcote he had decided on the character and disposition of a man from his letters and the handwriting.
"Long before the days of Lavater, Shenstone in one of his letters said, 'I want to see Mrs. Jago's writing that I may judge of her temper.'
"One great truth must, however, be conceded to the opponents of the physiognomy of handwriting. General rules only can be laid down. Yet the vital principle must be true that the handwriting bears an analogy to the character of the writer, as all voluntary actions are characteristic of the individual."
* * * * *
Professor Foli, in his very useful work, "Handwriting as an Index to Character" (London: C. A. Pearson, Ltd.), says:
"The changes which handwriting undergoes as maturity is reached prove how directly it is influenced by the nervous condition of the writer.
"The writing proper to childhood is large, round and accompanied by a laboured pen movement; whereas that which is normal as manhood or womanhood is attained is smaller, and turned off by a more rapid and fluent motion of the hand.
"Illness, again, affects the writing. As the hand is charged with more or less of the nerve fluid, so the writing is stronger or weaker, firmer or feebler, as the case may be.
"This goes to show the important influence which the nerve current exerts in fashioning the handwriting. Small wonder that our handwriting alters day by day. Yet it does not alter either. So far as its general appearance is concerned I grant it _seems_ to do so. But look at the really significant points of the writing written at different times. Give a glance at the height at which the '_i_' is dotted, the way in which the '_t_' is barred, the manner in which the letters are, or are not, connected and finished off. These things will crop up with unerring uniformity time after time.
"You do, of course, get a studied handwriting now and then, just as you sometimes meet with a formed facial expression. But that does not express the true character, simply because the control over the feelings or the power of disguising what is felt is a salient point in the character; and this very fact will serve to show that there is truth in graphology.
"That the pen, whether it be a fine or a broad pointed nib, plays a certain part in determining the thickness or thinness of the strokes, I am willing to allow, but here again we have no argument against graphology, for most people have their favourite nib--just as they prefer one occupation to another--and this is the one which will best serve to define their characteristics. The same with the surface of the paper upon which they write; some will select a smooth, others a rough kind, but whatever that may be which is adopted with comfort, it will be typical of the writer."
The following are some of the more marked signs of the character they indicate. For a fuller exposition of their application it would be well to study the work of Foli, before mentioned, and of Rosa Baughan (Upcott Gill, London, 2_s._ 6_d._), with the scholarly work of J. Crépieux-Jainin, entitled, "Handwriting and Expression," translated by J. Holt Schooling.
* * * * *
_General Characteristic._--The fineness of an organism will be revealed by a fine light penstroke. Coarse, low natures make heavy blurred entangled lines.
_Activity_ is denoted by the length of the letters. Where it is feeble the letters will be widely spaced and rounded.
_Excitability_ is shown by sharp strokes and stops. The more acute and irregular the pen-strokes the greater the intensity of feeling.
_Aggression_, which is the inclination to attack, the destructive force, is indicated by the final strokes of letters and the cross-bars of _t_'s advancing well forward, the dots of the _i_'s placed well forward. In such a word as "time" the dot would probably be between the _m_ and _e_. The style is angular and well and evenly spaced, altogether a forward, "go-ahead" writing.
_Economy_, or acquisitiveness, is shown by the finishing strokes being turned backwards, and inwards; by a cramped hand, a disposition to curtail strokes, particularly the endings of letters, as if the expenditure of ink was begrudged.
_Secretiveness_, or extra caution, has its sign in the narrow, tightly-closed form of the body of the letters _a_, _d_, _g_, _o_, _q_, the _a_ and _o_ often being merely a narrow _v_. The general tendency of the writing is to compression, the final strokes being very short. When very marked, the letters dwindle into an indistinct unformed condition. The substitution of dashes for punctuation is another symptom.
_Insincerity._--Beware of the man or woman whose writing is a fine, wavy line, upright, with short, stumpy and indistinct tops and tails, words running at their end to an almost straight line, the letters merely indicated. The flatter, finer and more perpendicular this writing, the greater the insincerity. Such a writer would probably be a polite, pleasing and plausible person, but double-faced as Janus.
_Love of praise_, glory, ambition are shown by a tendency to write upwards, the lines of writing trending towards the right-hand corner of the paper. The signature will usually have a curved line below it, with a degree of flourish.
_Self-esteem_, to which is allied conceit and ostentation, shows itself in proportion to the size of the writing, the taller and more flourished the upstrokes and the longer the downstrokes, the greater the self-assertiveness. The flourish beneath the signature will be very pronounced, often an elaborate spider's web of interlaced lines. The writing is more or less angular with the finals turned backwards and inwards.
_Will power_ is shown by firm bars to the _t_, with a tendency to descend from left to right, bludgeon-like downstrokes to tailed letters, writing rather angular than rounded, and the final strokes finished by a heavy pressure. Straight, firm, downward strokes take the place of the tails to _y_, _g_, _f_, _q_.
_Sympathy_, good nature, kindness of heart are shown by a flowing open hand, the finals of the letters being extended and thrown out with an expansive movement. The tailed letters are long and looped, and often turned up the right side of the letter. The letters are well apart but not necessarily unconnected, and the style is curved. As a general rule hard matter-of-fact natures incline to an angular style; the artistic and softer nature affects rounded, gracefully curved strokes, and avoids straight perpendiculars or horizontals.
_Constructiveness_, which implies the ability to combine and connect words and phrases, is shown by joining the words together, several being written without lifting the pen from the paper. The more simple and ingenuous the method of attaching the words, the greater will be the ability. When this joining of words is carried to extremes, it may be taken as a sign of good deductive judgment.
_Observation_, by which is implied the keen, penetrating, inquiring mind (which in excess becomes curiosity), is marked by angularity of the strokes and finals; a small, generally neat, handwriting, with the letters disconnected.
_Punctuation_ affords a very valuable clue to character-reading, for reasons set out in the chapter "How to Study a Handwriting." They are the most mechanical and unpremeditated of hand-gestures, and are, therefore, the more valuable.
When, for example, a dot is thick and heavy, we infer that the pen has been driven across the paper with a strong, decided movement of the hand, which would be consistent with extreme energy and will power; whereas, when the dot is light and faintly indicated we may be certain that only a moderate force has been expended upon its production, which would be compatible with less resistance and endurance in the character.
Again, a dot whose outlines were blurred would show a certain sensuousness of character--strong passions and a want of restraint over the lower propensities; whereas, a dot whose edges were sharply defined would tell of refinement and a loathing against all that was coarse or vulgar.
Careful attention to punctuation indicates neatness, order, method and love of arrangement; nor is it necessary that the punctuation should be strictly correct, for the art is but imperfectly mastered by most people, even the best educated.
Stops that partake of the appearance of a comma indicate a degree of impetuosity; well rounded stops imply calmness and tranquility of temperament. When the full stops are fashioned after the form of a comma and droop towards the right hand they indicate a tendency to sulkiness. When they are merely angular we may infer impatience and a "peppery" disposition.
Flourishes are always indicative of a certain amount of assertiveness. The simpler the flourish the less artificial this self-insistence; the more elaborate, the greater the desire to seem what one is not.
BIBLIOGRAPHY OF HANDWRITING.
Most of the works in this list relate to that aspect of the study of graphology which is supposed to bear upon the manifestations of character. But there is not one which the student of handwriting can afford to ignore, since, apart from the debatable question of character reading, they all contain numerous hints and observations of extreme value to the student whose objective is the acquisition of aptitude in the more practical art of detecting forgery.
AUTOGRAPH COLLECTING: A practical manual for Amateurs and Historical Students. By HENRY T. SCOTT, M.D. London: Upcott Gill. Price 5_s._
A GUIDE TO THE COLLECTION OF HISTORICAL DOCUMENTS, LITERARY MSS. AND AUTOGRAPH LETTERS, &c. By Rev. H. T. SCOTT and SAMUEL DAVEY. (Out of print.) May be seen in British Museum and many public libraries.
THE AUTOGRAPHIC MIRROR: A monthly journal now defunct, but procurable at second hand.
HANDWRITING AND EXPRESSION. Translated and edited by JOHN HOLT SCHOOLING, from the third French edition of "L'Escriture et le Caractere," par J. CRÉPIEUX-JAININ. Kegan, Paul and Trench.
CHARACTER INDICATED BY HANDWRITING. By ROSA BAUGHAN. Upcott Gill. Price 2_s._ 6_d._
THE PHILOSOPHY OF HANDWRITING. By DON FELIX DE SALAMANCA. Macmillan.
HOW TO READ CHARACTER IN HANDWRITING. By HENRY FRITH. Ward Lock. Price 1_s._
HANDWRITING AS AN INDEX TO CHARACTER. By Professor FOLI. C. A. Pearson. Price 1_s._
A SYSTEM OF GRAPHOLOGY. By the ABBÉ MICHON. In French; no English translation. A valuable work.
A HISTORY OF HANDWRITING. Same Author.
A METHOD OF GRAPHOLOGIC STUDY. Same Author.
A MEMOIR UPON THE FAULTY METHODS USED BY EXPERTS IN HANDWRITING. Same Author.
A DICTIONARY OF THE NOTABILITIES OF FRANCE JUDGED FROM THE HANDWRITING. Same Author.
THE HANDWRITING OF THE FRENCH PEOPLE SINCE THE MEROVINGIAN EPOCH. Same Author.
LES MYSTÉRES DE L'ÉCRITURE. Preface by Desbarrolles. Same Author.
THE HANDWRITING OF JUNIUS PROFESSIONALLY EXAMINED BY CHABOT. Edited by the Hon. E. TWISTLETON. John Murray. 1871.
This work is the only one hitherto published in England explaining the methods of the handwriting expert. Mons. Chabot, for many years the leading English expert, was commissioned by Mr. Twistleton to examine the handwriting of "Junius" with a view to deciding the authorship of the famous letters. The result was an exhaustive volume in which the process of handwriting analysis is illustrated by thousands of examples. The conclusion arrived at was that the writer of the "Junius" letters was Sir Philip Francis.
_Literary and Historical Autograph Letters and Manuscripts Purchased._
OPINIONS GIVEN AS TO
GENUINENESS OF DOCUMENTS.
ALSO ON
SUSPECTED FORGERIES
AND
ANONYMOUS LETTERS.
BY
BLACKBURN & CADDELL, 19, CHARLWOOD PLACE, LONDON, S.W.
Transcriber's Note:
Minor typographical errors have been corrected without note, whilst more significant amendments have been listed below.
Page 37, 'analine' amended to _aniline_. Page 53, 'Alcebiades' amended to _Alcibiades_. Page 56, 'correspence' amended to _correspondence_. Page 56, 'addresss' amended to _address_. Page 68, 'four documents' amended to _five documents_. Page 78, 'MERORINGIAN' amended to _MEROVINGIAN_.