Category: History - Modern (1750+)

A history of economic doctrines

Political Economy as the name of a special science is the invention of one Antoine de Montchrétien, who first employed the term about the beginning of the seventeenth century. Not until the middle of the eighteenth century, however, does the connotation of the word in any way...

Chapters

1. CHAPTER I: THE PHYSIOCRATS (M. GIDE) 1

2. CHAPTER II: ADAM SMITH (M. RIST) 50

3. CHAPTER III: THE PESSIMISTS (M. GIDE) 118

4. CHAPTER I: SISMONDI AND THE ORIGINS OF THE CRITICAL SCHOOL

5. CHAPTER II: SAINT-SIMON, THE SAINT-SIMONIANS, AND THE BEGINNINGS

6. CHAPTER III: THE ASSOCIATIVE SOCIALISTS 231

7. CHAPTER IV: FRIEDRICH LIST AND THE NATIONAL SYSTEM OF POLITICAL

8. CHAPTER V: PROUDHON AND THE SOCIALISM OF 1848 (M. RIST) 290

9. CHAPTER I: THE OPTIMISTS (M. GIDE) 322

10. CHAPTER II: THE APOGEE AND DECLINE OF THE CLASSICAL SCHOOL. JOHN

11. CHAPTER I: THE HISTORICAL SCHOOL AND THE CONFLICT OF METHODS

12. CHAPTER II: STATE SOCIALISM (M. RIST) 407

13. CHAPTER III: MARXISM (M. GIDE) 449

14. CHAPTER IV: DOCTRINES THAT OWE THEIR INSPIRATION TO CHRISTIANITY

15. CHAPTER I: THE HEDONISTS (M. GIDE) 517

16. CHAPTER II: THE THEORY OF RENT AND ITS APPLICATIONS (M. RIST) 545

17. CHAPTER III: THE SOLIDARISTS (M. GIDE) 587

18. CHAPTER IV: THE ANARCHISTS (M. RIST) 614

19. CHAPTER I: THE PHYSIOCRATS

Political Economy as the name of a special science is the invention of one Antoine de Montchrétien, who first employed the term about the beginning of the seventeenth century. N...

20. CHAPTER II: ADAM SMITH

Notwithstanding the originality and vigour displayed by the Physiocrats, they can only be regarded as the heralds of the new science. Adam Smith,[126] it is now unanimously agre...

21. CHAPTER III: THE PESSIMISTS

A new point of view is presented to us by the economists of whom we are now going to speak. Hitherto we have heard with admiration of the discovery of new facts and of their ben...

22. BOOK II: THE ANTAGONISTS

It would, of course, be extravagant to imagine that these three writers were unanimous on all questions. There were several points that still remained obscure, and more than one...

23. CHAPTER I: SISMONDI AND THE ORIGINS OF THE CRITICAL SCHOOL

Economic Liberalism had everywhere become triumphant. In France the corporation era was definitely at an end by 1791. Some manufacturers, it is true, demanded its re-establishme...

24. CHAPTER II: SAINT-SIMON, THE SAINT-SIMONIANS, AND THE BEGINNINGS OF

Sismondi, by supplementing the study of political economy by a study of social economics, had already much enlarged the area traced for the science by its founders. But while gi...

25. CHAPTER III: THE ASSOCIATIVE SOCIALISTS

The name “Associative Socialists” is given to all those writers who believe that voluntary association on the basis of some preconceived plan is sufficient for the solution of a...

26. CHAPTER IV: FRIEDRICH LIST AND THE NATIONAL SYSTEM OF POLITICAL ECONOMY

By the middle of the nineteenth century the doctrine of Adam Smith had conquered the whole of Europe. Former theories were forgotten and no rival had appeared to challenge its s...

27. CHAPTER V: PROUDHON AND THE SOCIALISM OF 1848

Proudhon comes next, though his place in the history of economic doctrines is not easily defined. Like all socialists he begins with a criticism of the rights of property. The e...

28. BOOK III: LIBERALISM

It is time we returned to the Classical writers. Now that the combat had grown fierce among its critics, we are anxious to know what the Classical school itself was doing to rep...

29. CHAPTER I: THE OPTIMISTS

The previous Book has shown us the unsettled state of economic science. It has also indicated how the science was turned from its original course by reverses suffered at the han...

30. CHAPTER II: THE APOGEE AND DECLINE OF THE CLASSICAL SCHOOL. JOHN STUART

While the French economists, alarmed at the consequences involved in the theories of Malthus and Ricardo, strove to transmute the Brazen laws into Golden ones, the English econo...

31. BOOK IV: THE DISSENTERS

With Bastiat economic Liberalism, threatened by socialism, sought precarious refuge in Optimism. With Mill the older doctrines found new expression in language scientific in its...

32. CHAPTER I: THE HISTORICAL SCHOOL AND THE CONFLICT OF METHODS

The second half of the nineteenth century is dominated by Historical ideas, though their final triumph was not fully established until the last quarter of the century. The rise...

33. CHAPTER II: STATE SOCIALISM

The nineteenth century opened with a feeling of contempt for government of every kind, and with unbounded confidence on the part of at least every publicist in the virtue of eco...

34. CHAPTER III: MARXISM

Everyone knows of the spell cast over the socialism of the last forty years by the doctrines of Karl Marx and the contempt with which this newer so-called scientific socialism r...

35. CHAPTER IV: DOCTRINES THAT OWE THEIR INSPIRATION TO CHRISTIANITY

Everyone who knows the Bible at all or has the slightest acquaintance with the writings of the early Fathers must have been struck by the number of texts which they contain bear...

36. BOOK V: RECENT DOCTRINES

In the earlier sections of this work no special difficulty was experienced in giving the essential traits of the economic thought of each period. But on the threshold of this la...

37. CHAPTER I: THE HEDONISTS

If we are to give this new doctrine its true setting we must return for a moment to our study of the Historical school. The criticism of that school, as we have already seen, wa...

38. CHAPTER II: THE THEORY OF RENT AND ITS APPLICATIONS

The revival of interest in Classical theories, of which mention was made in the last chapter, cannot be passed over without a special reference to the theory of rent. The theory...

39. CHAPTER III: THE SOLIDARISTS

The word “solidarity,” formerly a term of exclusively legal import,[1249] has during the last twenty years been employed to designate a doctrine which has aroused the greatest e...

40. CHAPTER IV: THE ANARCHISTS

The social creed of the anarchist is a curious fusion of Liberal and socialist doctrines. Its economic criticism of the State, its enthusiasm for individual initiative, as well...

41. Book V.) The language is identical with that of the Physiocrats. But

there is this great difference. Rousseau thought that the state of nature had been denaturalised by social and especially by political institutions, including, of course, privat...

42. part iii; vol. ii, p. 128.)

The correspondence between selling price and the cost of production seemed to Smith to be of the very essence of justice. Complete correspondence would realise the ideal of the...

43. part iii (vol. i, pp. 4 and 240), and in Book II, chap. 3 (vol. i, pp.

[192] All these questions so obscurely treated in Smith’s work are handled with admirable lucidity in Irving Fisher’s _Nature of Capital and Income_ (New York, 1907). Revenue is...

44. part ii; vol. ii, pp. 90, 91.)

[200] “It is thus that the private interests and passions of individuals naturally dispose them to turn their stock towards the employments which in ordinary cases are most adva...

45. Book II, chap. 5; Cannan, vol. i, p. 351.) The expression “the political

[210] _Wealth of Nations_, Book I, chap. 8; Cannan, vol. i, p. 68. The masters possess the advantage in discussion (1) because they can combine much more easily; (2) because, th...

46. Book I.

[230] “Each of those different branches of trade, however, is not only advantageous, but necessary and unavoidable, when the course of things, without any constraint or violence...

47. Book II, chap. 5; Cannan’s edition, vol. i, p. 351.)

48. Book II, chap. 4.

[579] “The German nation will at once obtain what it is now in need of, namely, fisheries and naval power, maritime commerce and colonies.” (_National System_, p. 143.) List has...

49. Book IV, chap. 7, § 6.)

[789] The co-operative movement probably suggested this idea to him. He several times expresses the opinion that middlemen’s profits exceed those of the capitalists, and that th...

50. Book III, chap. 6). He has given it that name in order to facilitate

comparison with producer’s rent, which had gained notoriety long before the Hedonistic school arose. Both are due to similar causes, namely, the existence of differential advant...

51. Book III, chap. 5, § 4.) For the position with regard to mines see the

[1175] In this case Stuart Mill seems to compare rent to a monopoly revenue: “A thing which is limited in quantity, even though its possessors do not act in concert, is still a...