Part 1

Produced by Louise Hope, Juliet Sutherland and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net

[Transcriber's Note:

Two other papers from ASCE _Transactions_ LXVIII (September 1910) are referenced in this paper:

No. 1150, "The New York Tunnel Extension..." by Charles W. Raymond, available from Project Gutenberg as e-text #18229.

No. 1151, "The North River Division" by Charles M. Jacobs, e-text #18548, generally cited as "the paper by Mr. Jacobs".

The word "Figure" is used in two ways. It refers either to individual numbered Figures (1-21), or to any of the four pictures that make up each Plate, identified in the form "Fig. 2, Plate XXI". Figures 1-4 are always discussed as a group.

Single letters in boldface are shown as =A=. Typographical errors are listed at the end of the text.]

* * * * * * * * * * * * * *

American Society of Civil Engineers Instituted 1852 TRANSACTIONS

Paper No. 1154

THE NEW YORK TUNNEL EXTENSION OF THE PENNSYLVANIA RAILROAD. THE BERGEN HILL TUNNELS.[1]

By F. LAVIS, M. Am. Soc. C. E.

[Footnote 1: Presented at the meeting of April 6th, 1910.]

_Location._--That section of the Pennsylvania Railroad's New York Tunnels lying west of the Hudson River is designated Section "K," and the tunnels are generally spoken of as the Bergen Hill Tunnels. Bergen Hill is a trap dike (diabase) forming the lower extension of the Hudson River Palisades.

There are two parallel single-track tunnels, cross-sections of which are shown on Plate VIII of the paper by Charles M. Jacobs, M. Am. Soc. C. E. The center line is a tangent, and nearly on the line of 32d Street, New York City, produced, its course being N. 50° 30' W. The elevation of the top of the rail at the Weehawken Shaft (a view of which is shown by Fig. 2, Plate XXII), on the west bank of the Hudson River, is about 64 ft. below mean high water; and at the Western Portal, or Hackensack end, the rail is about 17 ft. above; the grade throughout is 1.3%, ascending from east to west. The length of each tunnel between the portals is 5,920 ft.

A general plan and profile of these tunnels is shown on Plate I of the paper by Charles W. Raymond, M. Am. Soc. C. E. At Central Avenue a shaft 212 ft. deep was sunk. It is 3,620 ft. from the Weehawken Shaft.

_History._--The contract for this work was let on March 6th, 1905, to the John Shields Construction Company; it was abandoned by the Receiver for that company on January 20th, 1906, and on March 20th, of that year, was re-let to William Bradley, who completed the work by December 31st, 1908.

The progress of excavation and lining in the North Tunnel is shown graphically on the progress diagram, Fig. 9, that of the South Tunnel being practically the same.

_Geology._--Starting west from the Weehawken Shaft, the tunnels pass through a wide fault for a distance of nearly 400 ft., this fault being a continuation of that which forms the valley between the detached mass of trap and sandstone known as King's Bluff, which lies north of the tunnels, and the main trap ridge of Bergen Hill.

The broken ground of the fault, which consists of decomposed sandstone, shale, feldspar, calcite, etc., interspersed with masses of harder sandstone and baked shale, gradually merges into a compact granular sandstone, which, at a distance of 460 ft. from the shaft, was self-supporting, and did not require timbering, which, of course, had been necessary up to this point.

A full face of sandstone continued to Station 274 + 60, 940 ft. from the shaft, where the main overlying body of trap appeared in the heading. The full face of the tunnel was wholly in trap at about Station 275 + 30, and continued in this through to the Western Portal, where the top of the trap was slightly below the roof of the tunnel, with hardpan above. The contact between the sandstone and the overlying trap was very clearly defined, the angle of dip being approximately 17° 40' toward the northwest.

The sandstone and trap are of the Triassic Period, and the trap of this vicinity is more particularly classified as diabase.

The character of the trap rock varied considerably. At the contact, at Station 275, and for a distance of approximately 200 ft. west, corresponding to a thickness of about 60 ft. measured at right angles to the line of the contact, a very hard, fine-grained trap, almost black in color, was found, having a specific gravity of 2.98, and weighing 186 lb. per cu. ft. The hardness of this rock is attested by the fact that the average time required to drill a 10-ft. hole in the heading, with a No. 34 slugger drill, with air at 90 lb. pressure, was almost 10 hours. The specific gravity of this rock is not as high as that of some other specimens of trap tested, which were much more easily drilled. This rock was very blocky, causing the drills to bind and stick badly, and, when being shoveled back from the heading, as it fell it sounded very much as though it were broken glass.

The remainder of the trap varied from this, through several changes of texture and color, due to different amounts of quartz and feldspar, to a very coarse-grained rock, closely resembling granite of a light color, though quite hard. The speed of drilling the normal trap in the heading was approximately 20 to 25 min. per ft., as compared with the 60 min. per ft. noted above, the larger amounts of quartz and feldspar accounting for the greater brittleness and consequently the easier drilling qualities of the rock. The normal trap in these tunnels has a specific gravity varying from 2.85 to 3.04, and weighs from 179 to 190 lb. per cu. ft.

The temperature of the tunnels, at points 1,000 ft. from the portals at both ends, remained nearly stationary, and approximately between 50° in winter and 60° in summer, up to the time the headings were holed through, being practically unaffected by daily changes in the temperature outside. At the western end, after the connection with the Central Shaft headings was made, there was almost always a current of air from the portal to the shaft, and ascending through the latter. This tended to make the temperature in this part of the tunnel correspond more nearly with the outside temperature; in fact, the variation was seldom more than 5° Fahr.

_Timbering._--These tunnels have been excavated entirely by the center top heading method, almost invariably used in the United States. Timbering, where required, was of the usual segmental form with outside lagging, as shown in several of the photographs. In a few places it was necessary to hold the ground as the work progressed, and, in such cases, crown bars were used in the headings.

There was some little trouble at the Western Portal, where the top of the rock was very near the roof of the tunnel, as shown by Fig. 1, Plate XXI. A side heading was driven at the level of the springing line until a point was reached where the roof was self-supporting, and the timbering was brought out to the face of the portal from that point.

_Drilling._--Where no timbering was required, several different methods were used in drilling and excavating the solid rock, though in all cases a center top heading was driven. The four diagrams, Figs. 1, 2, 3, and 4, give typical examples of these methods and show, in the order of their numbers, the general tendency of the development from a small heading kept some distance ahead of the bench, to a large heading with the bench kept close to it. The notes on each diagram give the general details of the quantity of drilling and powder used, methods of blasting, etc., and on the progress profile, Fig. 6, is indicated those portions of the tunnels in which each method was used.

All the drills used throughout the work by Mr. Bradley were Rand No. 34 sluggers, with 3-5/8-in. cylinders, and the steel was that known as the "Black Diamond Brand," 1-3/8-in., octagon. It was used in 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, and 12-ft. lengths; toward the end of the work it was proposed to use 14-ft. lengths, but owing to some delay in delivery this length was never obtained. The starters, 18 to 24 in. long, were sharpened to 2¾ to 3-in. gauge, which was generally held up to depths of 6 ft.; then the gauge gradually decreased until it was 1¾ to 2¼ in. at the bottom of a 12-ft. hole. Frequently, as many as three or four starters were used in starting a hole, and generally two sharpenings were required for each 2 ft. drilled, after the first 6 ft. It is estimated that about ¼ in. of steel was used for each sharpening, and that there was an average of one sharpening for every foot drilled.

The total quantity of steel used up, lost, or scrapped on the whole work was almost exactly 1 ft. for each 10 cu. yd. excavated, equal to 1¼ in. of steel per yard, distributed approximately as follows:

Sharpening ¾ to 7/8 in. Other losses ½ to 3/8 " --------------- Total 1¼ in. per cu. yd.

An "Ajax" drill sharpener was used, and proved very satisfactory. Rubber and cotton hose, covered with woven marlin, was used for the bench (3 in. inside diameter, in 50-ft. lengths), for drills (1 in. in diameter, in 25-ft. lengths), and for steam shovels (2½ in. in diameter, in 50-ft. lengths). Hose coverings of wound marlin, and of woven marlin with spiral steel wire covering were tried, but were not satisfactory, owing to the unwinding of the marlin and the bending of the steel covering.

Drilling Method No. 1: Small heading, 60 to 80 ft. long. Two columns used in heading, with two drills on each. Drills on sub-bench and main bench mounted on tripods.

+--------------------------------------------------+ | Per Round | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+ | | Total | No. of | Pounds | | | | Depth | Cubic | of | Advance | | | Drilled | Yards | Dynamite | | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+ | Heading | 140-155 | 18-21.6 | 93-131 | 5-6 | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+ | Bench | 110-120 | 53-60 | 76-97 | 3½-4 | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+

+---------+--------------------+-----------------------------+ | | Per Cubic Yard | Per linear Foot of Tunnel | | +---------+----------+-------+---------+-----------+ | | Linear | Pounds | Cubic | No. of | Pounds | | | Feet | of | Yards | Feet | of | | | Drilled | Dynamite | | Drilled | Dynamite | +---------+---------+----------+-------+---------+-----------+ | Heading | 8-9 | 5-6 | 3.6 | 29.-32 | 18-22 | +---------+---------+----------+-------+---------+-----------+ | Bench | 2 | 1.4-1.6 | 15.4 | 30.-31 | 21.5-24.6 | +---------+---------+----------+-------+---------+-----------+ | Total | 19 | 59.63 | 39.5-46.6 | +------------------------------+-------+---------+-----------+ | Per cubic yard, whole tunnel section | 3 to 33 | 2.1-2.5 | +--------------------------------------+---------+-----------+

+---------------------------------------------------+------------+ | | Number | | Blasting Notes: | of Sticks | | +------------+ | Heading: First Round: 6 sticks, 60% in each cut | | | hole, cut generally blasted twice | 36 to 72 | | Second Round: 3 side holes each side, | | | 5 sticks, 40% ea. | 30 | | Third Round: Rest of side holes and dry | | | holes, 5 sticks, 40% each | 40 | | Stub holes, say | 5 to 15 | | +------------+ | Total Sticks | 111 to 157 | | +------------+ | Total Pounds | 93 to 131 | | +------------+ | Sub-bench: 4 widening holes; 2 to 3 sticks, | | | each, 40% | 10 to 12 | | 6 down holes; 5 to 7 sticks, each, 40% | 30 to 42 | | Bench: 6 holes; 6 to 8 sticks each, 40% | 36 to 48 | | Taking up bottom, average, say | 15 | | +------------+ | Total Sticks | 91 to 117 | | +------------+ | Total Pounds | 76 to 97 | +---------------------------------------------------+------------+

Drilling Method, No. 2: Five drills in heading, mounted on three columns; the holes marked with a cross (X) were drilled with the drills on the center column.

+--------------------------------------------------+ | Per Round | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+ | | Total | No. of | Pounds | | | | Depth | Cubic | of | Advance | | | Drilled | Yards | Dynamite | | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+ | Heading | 190-220 | 35-42 | 134-196 | 6½-8 | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+ | Bench | 110-130 | 55 | 79-106 | 4 | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+

+---------+--------------------+-----------------------------+ | | Per Cubic Yard | Per linear Foot of Tunnel | | +---------+----------+-------+---------+-----------+ | | Linear | Pounds | Cubic | No. of | Pounds | | | Feet | of | Yards | Feet | of | | | Drilled | Dynamite | | Drilled | Dynamite | +---------+---------+----------+-------+---------+-----------+ | Heading | 5.4-6.0 | 3.9-5.0 | 5.3 |28 to 32.| 20.7-26.5 | +---------+---------+----------+-------+---------+-----------+ | Bench | 2.-2.4 | 1.4-2.0 | 13.7 | 27.-33. | 19.2-27.4 | +---------+---------+----------+-------+---------+-----------+ | Total | 19 | 55.-65. | 39.9-53.9 | +------------------------------+-------+---------+-----------+ | Per cubic yard, whole tunnel section | 2.9-3.4 | 2.1-2.8 | +--------------------------------------+---------+-----------+

+---------------------------------------------------+------------+ | | Number | | Blasting Notes: | of Sticks | | +------------+ | Heading: First Round; 2 to 3 relieving holes | | | sprung with 4 to 5 sticks each | 8 to 15 | | 8 cut holes, 7 sticks each | | | (sometimes shot twice) | 56 to 112 | | First side round, 6 holes, 6 sticks | | | each | 36 | | Widening and dry holes, 10 to 12, | | | 6 sticks each | 60 to 72 | | +------------+ | Total Sticks | 160 to 235 | | +------------+ | Total Pounds | 134 to 196 | | ----------------+------------+ | Sub-bench: 8 holes, 4 to 6 sticks, each | 32 to 48 | | | | | Bench: 8 holes, 6 to 8 sticks, each | 46 to 64 | | Taking up bottom, average | 15 | | +------------+ | Total Sticks | 95 to 127 | | +------------+ | Total Pounds | 79 to 109 | +---------------------------------------------------+------------+

Drilling Method No. 3: Heading same as second method, but larger lift taken off bench, and lift holes drilled in bottom bench in order to get down to grade in floor. Bench kept closer to heading.

+---------------------------------------------------------+ | Per Round | +---------+------------+-----------+------------+---------+ | | Total | No. of | Pounds | | | | Depth | Cubic | of | Advance | | | Drilled | Yards | Dynamite | | +---------+------------+-----------+------------+---------+ | Heading | 190 to 220 | 35 to 42 | 134 to 196 | 6½ to 8 | +---------+------------+-----------+------------+---------+ | | | | | | | Bench | 145 " 190 | 90 to 110 | 118 " 167 | 6½ " 8 | +---------+------------+-----------+------------+---------+

+-----+-------------------------+----------------------------------+ | | Per Cubic Yard | Per linear Foot of Tunnel | | +------------+------------+-------+-----------+--------------+ | | Linear | Pounds | Cubic | No. of | Pounds | | | Feet | of | Yards | Feet | of | | | Drilled | Dynamite | | Drilled | Dynamite | +-----+------------+------------+-------+-----------+--------------+ | Hd. | 5.4 to 6.0 | 3.9 to 5.0 | 5.3 | 28 to 32 | 20.7 to 26.5 | +-----+------------+------------+-------+-----------+--------------+ | B. | 1.6 " 1.9 | 1.3 " 1.8 | 13.7 | 22 " 36 | 17.8 " 24.7 | +-----+------------+------------+-------+-----------+--------------+ | Total | 19 | 50 " 58 | 38.5 " 51.2 | +-------------------------------+-------+-----------+--------------+ | Per cubic yard, whole tunnel section | 2.6 " 3.1 | 2.0 " 2.6 | +---------------------------------------+-----------+--------------+

+---------------------------------------------------+------------+ | | Number | | Blasting Notes: | of Sticks | | +------------+ | Heading: First Round: 2 to 3 relieving holes | | | sprung, with 4 to 5 sticks each | 8 to 15 | | 8 cut holes, 7 sticks each | | | (sometimes shot twice) | 56 to 112 | | First side round, 6 holes, 6 sticks | | | each | 36 | | Widening and dry holes, 10 to 12 holes, | | | 6 sticks each | 60 to 72 | +---------------------------------------------------+------------+ | Total Sticks | 160 to 235 | +---------------------------------------------------+------------+ | Total Pounds | 134 to 196 | +---------------------------------------------------+------------+ | | | | Sub-bench: 4 widening holes, 4 to 5 sticks each, | | | 2 rounds | 32 to 40 | | 6 down holes, 5 to 7 sticks each, | | | 2 rounds | 60 to 84 | | | | | Bench: 4 down holes, 5 to 7 sticks each | 20 to 28 | | 6 to 8 lift holes, 5 to 6 sticks each | 30 to 48 | +---------------------------------------------------+------------+ | Total Sticks | 142 to 200 | +---------------------------------------------------+------------+ | Total Pounds | 118 to 167 | +---------------------------------------------------+------------+

Drilling Method No. 4: 8 drills on 4 columns used in heading. Bench taken off in one lift. Bottom taken up with lift holes.

+--------------------------------------------------+ | Per Round | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+ | | Total | No. of | Pounds | | | | Depth | Cubic | of | Advance | | | Drilled | Yards | Dynamite | | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+ | Heading | 310-320 | 63-71 | 215-257 | 8-9 | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+ | Bench | 190-210 | 89-100 | 107-155 | 8-9 | +---------+---------+---------+----------+---------+

+---------+--------------------+------------------------------+ | | Per Cubic Yard | Per linear Foot of Tunnel | | +---------+----------+-------+----------+-----------+ | | Linear | Pounds | Cubic | No. of | Pounds | | | Feet | of | Yards | Feet | of | | | Drilled | Dynamite | | Drilled | Dynamite | +---------+---------+----------+-------+----------+-----------+ | Heading | 4.5-5.1 | 3.4-5.7 | 7.9 | 35.6-45. | 26.9-45.0 | +---------+---------+----------+-------+----------+-----------+ | Bench | 1.9-2.2 | 1.2-1.7 | 11.1 | 21.1-24. | 13.3-18.9 | +---------+---------+----------+-------+----------+-----------+ | Total | 19 | 56.7-69. | 40.2-63.9 | +------------------------------+-------+----------+-----------+ | Per cubic yard, whole tunnel section | 3.-3.6 | 2.1-3.4 | +--------------------------------------+----------+-----------+