St. Gregory and the Gregorian Music
Chapter 3
It is natural to think of his Schola Cantorum in this connection. The foundation of this must have had a profound effect both on the standard of the performance of the chant, and on the spread of the Gregorian reform. Books were scarce in those days, and musical notation defective. Teaching was chiefly by word of mouth. The Director of the Choir had his manuscript to teach from, and his pupils had to learn the melodies by heart. The chief singer also had his _liber cantatorius_ from which to sing the solos, such as the Graduals and Tracts. The School was, necessarily, not merely for teaching correct versions of the chant, but for preserving the correct tradition of the method of performance. Most of the seventh century popes were connected with the School or proceeded from it.
The skilled musicians belonging to this School may have helped to carry out the reform under Gregory's direction. But no tradition appears to have been preserved to that effect, and the unity and uniform characteristics seem to point to the work of one genius, even in the smallest details; and the characteristics there displayed seem to fit in with what we know from other sources of his character, in his writings and in his actions.
In conclusion it is submitted that the evidence here put forward, though in some respects rather scanty, yet, in the absence of any strong evidence to the contrary, is quite sufficient to justify the tradition that St. Gregory was the organiser, reformer, and to some extent the author of the Antiphoner of the Mass. It is, of course, more difficult to say definitely what his work actually was in these three divisions, but a quite sufficient amount of certainty has been attained for us to realize the extent and the nature of the debt which succeeding ages have owed to the great Pope, and so far the attacks that have been made on the tradition have only resulted in setting it on a firmer and more definite basis.
THE PORTRAITS OF ST. GREGORY.
The oldest portrait of which we have a record is one of which a very full description was given by John the Deacon, Gregory's biographer. This likeness was to be seen in John's day (in the latter part of the ninth century) in Gregory's house, which he had converted into a monastery, in a small room behind the brethren's store-room or granary. It was surrounded by a circular plaster frame. Probably the whole figure was not represented; at all events, the following description which he gives stops at the hands.
"His figure was of ordinary height, and was well made; his face was a happy medium between the length of his father's and the roundness of his mother's face, so that with a certain roundness it seemed to be of a very comely length, his beard being like his father's, of a rather tawny colour, and of moderate length. He was rather bald, so that in the middle of his forehead he had two small neat curls, twisted towards the right; the crown of his head was round and large, his darkish hair being nicely curled and hanging down as far as the middle of his ear; his forehead was high, his eyebrows long and elevated; his eyes had dark pupils, and though not large were open, under full eyelids; his nose from the starting-point of his curving eyebrows being thin and straight, broader about the middle, slightly aquiline, and expanded at the nostrils; his mouth was red, lips thick and sub-divided; his cheeks were well-shaped, and his chin of a comely prominence from the confines of the jaws; his colour was swarthy and ruddy, not, as it afterwards became, unhealthy looking; his expression was kindly; he had beautiful hands, with tapering fingers, well adapted for writing."
The description goes on to say that Gregory wore the _penula_ (cloak) of chestnut colour, and over it the sacred pall, and that in his hands he carried the book of the Gospel. We learn, further, that he did not have the round nimbus, but a rectangular or square one, with which it was the custom to adorn the heads of portraits of eminent people in their life-time. John considers this a sure proof that the painting was executed during the life of the saint; if it had been done after his death, he would have been given a circular nimbus.
In the same monastery were portraits of his father and mother, Gordianus and Silvia. But of course all have been destroyed.
The portrait (_frontispiece_) here reproduced is a reconstruction from John the Deacon's description, made by Angelo Rocca, Bishop of Tagaste, and a noted archæologist of his time (1597). He combined the three portraits in one.
Another reconstruction from John the Deacon's description may be seen in _Rassegna Gregoriana_ for June, 1903. This follows the description more closely than does that of Rocca.
At a later date there grew up the custom of representing St. Gregory always with a dove. According to John the Deacon it was already customary in his day (_c._ 872). This is seen in our second illustration (_opposite page_ 11), taken from the Antiphoner of the monk Hartker of St. Gall (date between 986 and 1011). This illustration has the characteristics found in the greater number of representations of Gregory; the dove (the symbol of the Holy Ghost) is represented as inspiring him, and he is dictating to the scribe, who is said to be the deacon Peter. The veneration felt for his writings, and in particular those of the ecclesiastical chant, was such that they were felt to be due directly to the inspiration of the Holy Ghost. Here the Pope is represented as wearing an alb, a dalmatic, a _planeta_ and over it the sacred pall, and on his left forearm, a maniple.
The third picture (_opposite page_ 16) is prefixed to two Coronation Services in a miscellaneous volume formerly belonging to Christ Church, Canterbury, on a page now numbered 8. The pages 9-18 comprise a Coronation Service of the x./xi. century, and on pp. 19-29 there follows another service of the xiiith century. On p. 30 is another picture, probably of German workmanship, representing a man writing. Each seems to be independent of its surrounding leaves; there seems no connection between the two, unless it be that they depict the same person.
The former of the two clearly depicts St. Gregory; it has been constantly said on the strength of the legend above, "Dunstani Archiepiscopi," that it represents St. Dunstan, but the dove points clearly to St. Gregory; the legend is possibly a later addition, and if St. Dunstan is to be found upon the page at all it is in the archiepiscopal figure kissing the toe of the great figure. This act of homage suggests that the large figure represents a Pope. Moreover, St. Dunstan is shown prostrate at the feet of Christ in another picture, which may very possibly be from the saint's own hand; it is, therefore, reasonable to identify him with the figure below. Possibly also it may be suggested that this picture, too, represents St. Dunstan's handiwork.
St. Gregory wears a pall over a yellow chasuble, and over this above is a red fringe ornament which is probably a rational. The purple dalmatic with scarlet border is very conspicuous under his chasuble; the under-vestments are less distinct, but the ends of the stole show over a very dark garment, which is, perhaps, a tunicle. The mitre is of very early shape. The archiepiscopal figure below wears a similar mitre, a pall over a light green chasuble; underneath a pink dalmatic and a purple show at the arms, as well as below.
The monk who balances him is in a white habit, but the figure kneeling below is in a black habit of the same pattern, ungirt, and with a cowl.
The colouring of the whole is crude, and the drawing lacks delicacy.
The fourth portrait (_opposite page_ 24) is taken from a MS. of _The Dialogues of St. Gregory_ (_Harl._ 3011), at the British Museum, _f._ 69 v., at the end of the 3rd book. The background is bright green, with a brown border round it. It is a brown-ink drawing, with some yellow wash. The inscription above it is _Teodericus depinxit hanc imaginem Gregorium patrem_. It exemplifies once again the symbol of the dove, which is here evidently not connected specially with the musical work of St. Gregory, but with his literary efforts as a whole.
THE PLAINSONG AND MEDIAEVAL MUSIC SOCIETY.
PRESIDENT.
The Right Hon. THE EARL OF DYSART.
VICE-PRESIDENTS.
The Right Rev. THE BISHOP OF ARGYLL and THE ISLES. Sir HICKMAN B. BACON, Bart. Sir J. F. BRIDGE, Mus. Doc. The Right Hon. THE VISCOUNT HALIFAX. The Very Rev. VERNON STALEY. H. ELLIS WOOLDRIDGE, Esq.
COUNCIL.
Rev. MAURICE BELL. W. J. BIRKBECK, Esq. Rev. A. E. BRIGGS. R. A. BRIGGS, Esq. SOMERS CLARKE, Esq. WAKELING DRY, Esq. Rev. W. HOWARD FRERE. A. HUGHES-HUGHES, Esq. J. T. MICKLETHWAITE, Esq. Rev. E. J. NORRIS. Rev. G. H. PALMER. A. H. D. PRENDERGAST, Esq. ATHELSTAN RILEY, Esq. J. RUSSELL, Esq. PERCY E. SANKEY, Esq. Rev. H. URLING SMITH. Rev. G. R. WOODWARD. E. G. P. WYATT, Esq.
AUDITORS.
_MESSRS. GERARD VAN DE LINDE & SON._
HON. TREASURER.
_E. G. P. WYATT, ESQ._
HON. SECRETARY.
_PERCY. E. SANKEY, ESQ., 44 Russell Square, London. W.C._
The Plainsong & Mediaeval Music Society.
The Society is founded for purely antiquarian purposes with the following objects:--
1. To be a centre of information in England for students of Plainsong and Mediaeval Music, and a means of communication between them and those of other countries.
2. To publish fac-similes of important MSS., translations of foreign works on the subject, adaptations of the Plainsong to the English Use, and such other works as may be desirable.
3. To form a catalogue of all Plainsong and Measured Music in England, dating not later than the middle of the sixteenth century.
4. To form a throughly proficient Choir of limited numbers, with which to give illustrations of Plainsong and Mediaeval Music.
The subscription for Members is £1 per annum, entitling them to all publications _gratis_. Clergymen and Organists are eligible for election as Associates, at a Subscription of 2/6 per annum, which will entitle them to the annual publications at a reduced price.
_______________ 190____
_Name_ ______________________________________________
_Address_ ___________________________________________
_requests to be admitted a Member (or Associate) of THE PLAINSONG & MEDIAEVAL MUSIC SOCIETY._
_Proposed by_ _______________________________________
_Seconded by_ _______________________________________
To be sent to the Hon. Secretary, P. E. Sankey, Esq, 44 Russell Square, London. W. C.
PUBLICATIONS OF THE SOCIETY.
Price.
THE MUSICAL NOTATION OF THE MIDDLE AGES (_out of print_) ...
SONGS & MADRIGALS OF THE 15th CENTURY, containing 14 specimens, with _fac-similes_ and rules for translating the music into modern notation (Quaritch) £1.6.
GRADUALE SARISBURIENSE, a _fac-simile_ of a 13th Century English Gradual, with an introduction giving a history of the development of the _Graduale_ from the _Antiphonale Missarum_ of St. Gregory, with elaborate Indexes to the Offices, Graduals, etc., and to works on Liturgiology. The volume contains 102 pages of Text and 293 pages of Collotypes, and represents the most important part of the Ecclesiastical Music of the Middle Ages (Quaritch) £4.2.
ANTIPHONALE SARISBURIENSE, a _fac-simile_ of a 13th Century English Antiphoner. This work, when complete, will be uniform with the _Graduale Sarisburiense_, and will contain over 700 pages of Collotypes. It is being published in yearly parts. Parts I, II, III & IV, now ready with portfolio, price £4.2.
THE SARUM GRADUAL, being the introduction to the GRADUALE SARISBURIENSE with four _fac-simile pages_ (Quaritch) 15/9
EARLY ENGLISH HARMONY, from the 10th to the 15th Century. Vol I., containing 60 Collotype Plates of music by composers from St. Dunstan down to John Dunstable (Quaritch) £1.6.
_The above works are folio and on thick paper._
MADRIGALS OF THE 15th CENTURY, containing six Madrigals in modern notation, _quarto_ (Novello) (_out of print_) ...
BIBLIOTHECA MUSICO-LITURGICA, a descriptive hand-list of the Musical and Latin Liturgical MSS. of the middle Ages preserved in English libraries. _Fascicle_ I. and _Fascicle_ II., making Vol. I., _quarto_, 164 pp. with 13 _facsimiles_ (Quaritch) £1.5.6.
S. GREGORY AND THE GREGORIAN MUSIC 2/8
THE ELEMENTS OF PLAINSONG, _édition de luxe_ (_out of print_) ...
THE ORDINARY OF THE MASS, _édition de luxe_ (Quaritch) 7/10
PLAINSONG HYMN-MELODIES & SEQUENCES, _édition de luxe_ (Quaritch) 7/10
RECENT RESEARCH IN PLAINSONG, _édition de luxe_ 3/3
_The above editions consist of numbered copies to which the issue is limited._
THE ELEMENTS OF PLAINSONG, cloth, 3/9
A GENERAL OUTLINE OF PLAINSONG (being Chapter I. of above) 3_d._
*CHOIR RESPONSES 3_d._
DEPRECAMUR TE (as sung by St. Augustine and his companions) 3_d._
THE INVITATORY PSALM (_Venite exultemus_), set to its Proper Melodies in the IIIrd, IVth, VIth and VIIth Modes each 3_d._
THE PASCHAL ANTHEMS (_Pascha nostrum_) 3_d._
TE DEUM 3_d._
MAGNIFICAT & BENEDICTUS set to the Peregrine Tone 3_d._
THE CANTICLES 5_d._
ADDITIONAL SETTINGS of certain of THE CANTICLES, being the four previous publications in one volume 10_d._
RESPONDS AT VESPERS for ADVENT, CHRISTMAS-TIDE, LENT, and COMMON OF SAINTS (Others in preparation) 2/3
*THE PSALM TONES & OFFICE RESPONSES 4_d._
THE SARUM PSALTER (Geo. Bell & Sons.). 2/10
THE INTRODUCTION to ditto, with the Tone-table and Examples 8_d._
*THE LITANY & SUFFRAGES Bound 8_d._
THE ANTIPHONS TO MAGNIFICAT 4/4
*THE ORDINARY OF THE MASS (7 Masses in English) 2/9, Cloth 3/9
*THE PLAINSONG OF THE HOLY COMMUNION, two easy melodies for the _Kyrie_, _Sanctus_, _Agnus_ & _Gloria in excelsis_, with the Creed & Choir Responses 7_d._
MISSA REX SPLENDENS (Organ accompaniment by Dr. Pearce) 1/2
*THE MUSIC OF THE MASS FOR THE DEAD, adapted to the English Text from the Sarum Manuale 1/8
VESPERS OF THE DEAD 5_d._
THE ORDER OF THE BURIAL OF THE DEAD 4_d._
PLAINSONG REQUIEM SERVICES, being Vespers, Mass & Burial of the Dead 2/8
*PLAINSONG HYMN-MELODIES AND SEQUENCES 2/9
The Words only of the Sequences together with sundry Eucharistic Hymns and Antiphons 7_d._
A SELECTION OF INTROITS, GRAILS & ALLELUYAS 2/4
EUCHARISTIC HYMNS & ANTIPHONS 10_d._
SALVE! FESTA DIES for 5 Great Festivals 7_d._
RULED MUSIC PAPER, per quire 8_d._
Organ accompaniments can be obtained in MS. from the Community of S. Mary the Virgin, Wantage.
*A reduction allowed to Choirs. _Prepayment is necessary in all cases._
_The above prices include the postage, and copies can be obtained upon application by letter with remittance of the Hon. Secretary_--
Percy E. Sankey, Esq. 44 Russell Square, London, W. C.
The Society has arranged for instruction in the correct rendering of plainsong to be given to Clergy, Organists and others, also for a Choirmaster to assist Choirs adopting the music. For particulars apply to the Hon. Secretary.