Scientific American Supplement, No. 613, October 1, 1887
Chapter 5
There are two methods of discharging in continuous working--the sugar is thrown out periodically as the basket fills, or continuously. In neither case is the speed slackened. In the first either the upper half of the basket has an upward motion, on the lower half a downward motion (Pat. 252,483); and through the opening thus made the sugar is thrown. Fig. 22 (R.B. Palmer & Sons) is a machine of this kind. The bottom, B, with the cone distributor, _a_, have downward motion.
Continuous discharge of the second kind may be brought about by having a scoop fixed to the curb (or casing), extending down into the basket and delivering the sugar over the side (Pat. 144,319). Another method will be described under "Beet Machines."
BASKET.--The construction of the basket is exceedingly important. Hard experience has taught this. When centrifugals were first introduced, users were compelled by law to put them below ground; for they frequently exploded, owing to the speed being suddenly augmented by inequalities in the running of the engine or to the basket being too weak to resist the centrifugal force of the overcharge. Increasing the thickness merely adds to the centrifugal force, and hence to the danger, as even a perfectly balanced basket may sever.
One plan for a better basket was to have more than one wall. For example, there might be an inner wall of perforated copper, then one of wire gauze, and then another of copper with larger perforations. Another plan was to have an internal metallic cloth, bearing against the internally projecting ridges of the corrugations of the basket wall. A further complication is to give this internal gauze cylinder a rotation relative to the basket.
The basket wall has been variously constructed. In one case it consists of wire wound round and round and fastened to uprights, commonly known as the "wire basket;" in another case of a periphery without perforations, but spirally corrugated and having an opening at the bottom for the escape of the extracted liquid; in still another of a series of narrow bars or rings, placed edgewise, packed as close as desired. An advantage of this last style is that it is easily cleaned.
The best basket consists of sheet metal with bored perforations and having bands or flanges sprung on around the outside. The metal is brass, if it is apt to be corroded; if not, sheet iron. The perforations may be round, or horizontally much longer than wide vertically. One method for the manufacture of the basket wall (Pat. 149,553) is to roll down a plate, having round perforations, to the required thickness, causing narrowing and elongation of the holes and at the same time hardening the plate by compacting its texture. Long narrow slots are well adapted to catch sugar crystals, and this is not an unimportant point. Round perforations are usually countersunk. Instead of flanges, wire bands have been used, their lapping ends secured by solder.
As to comparative wear, it maybe remarked that one perforated basket will outlast three wire ones.
As to size, sugar baskets vary from 80 inches in diameter by 14 in. depth to 54 by 24. They are made, however, in England as large as 6 feet in diameter--a size which can be run only at a comparatively slow speed.
A peculiar complication of basket deserves notice (Pat. 275 874). It had been noticed that when a charge of magma was put into a centrifugal in one mass, the sugar wall on the side of the basket was apt to form irregularly, too thick at base and of varied color. To remedy this it was suggested to have within and concentric with the basket a charger with flaring sides, into which the mixture was to be put. When this charger reached a certain rotary velocity, the magma would be hurled out over the edge by centrifugal force and evenly distributed on the wall of the main basket.
SPINDLE.--The spindle as now made is solid cast steel, and the considerations governing its size, form, material, etc., are identical with those for any spindle. In order that the basket might be replaced by another after draining, the shaft has been made telescopic, but at the expense of stability and rigidity. In Fig. 16 is shown a device to avoid crystallizations, which are apt to occur in large forgings, and would prove fatal should they creep into the upper part of the spindle proper in a hanging machine. It consists of the secondary spindle, _c_.
DISCHARGING.--The drained sugar may either be lifted over the top of the basket (in machines which stop to be emptied), or be cast through openings in the bottom provided with valves. A section of the best form of valve may be seen in Figs. 15 and 17. Fig. 23 is a plan of the openings. The valve turns on the basket bearing. It may be constructed to open in the same direction in which the basket turns; so that when the brake is put on, the inertia of the valve operates to open it and while running to keep it closed. There are many other styles, but no other need be mentioned.
CASING.--The different styles of casing may be seen by reference to the various drawings. In one machine (not described) the casing is rigidly fixed to the basket, space enough being left between the bottom of the basket and the bottom of the casing to hold all the molasses from a charge. This arrangement merely adds to the bulk of the revolving parts, and no real advantage is gained.
BEARINGS.--The various styles of bearings can be seen by reference to the figures. One which deserves special attention is shown in Fig. 16 and Fig. 19. In one case it consists of loose disks, in the other of loose washers, rotating on one another. They are alternately of steel and hard bronze (copper and tin).
"There is probably no machine so little understood or so imperfectly constructed by the common manufacturer of sugar supplies as the high speed separator or centrifugal." Unless the product of experience and good workmanship, it is a dangerous thing at high velocities. Besides, its usual fate is to have an incompetent workman assigned to it, who does not use judgment in charging and running. So that designers and manufacturers have been forced not only to take into account the disturbing forces inherent in revolving bodies, but also to make allowance for poor management in running and neglect in cleaning.
CANE AND BEET MACHINES.--The first step in the process of sugar making is the extraction of the juice from the beet or cane. This juice is obtained by pressure. The operation is not usually, but may be, performed in a special kind of centrifugal. One style (Pat. 239,222) consists of a conical basket with a spiral flange within on the shaft, and turning on the shaft, and having a slight rotary motion relative to the basket. The material is fed in and moves downward under increased pressure, the sirup released flying out through the perforations of the basket, the whole revolving at high velocity. The solid portion falls out at the bottom. Another plan suggested (Pat. 343,932) is to let a loose cover of an ordinary cylindrical basket screw itself down into the basket, by reason of its slower velocity (owing to inertia), causing pressure on the charge.
Various other applications of the different styles of sugar machines are the defibration of raw sugar juice, freeing beet crystals of objectionable salts, freeing various crystals of the mother liquor, drying saltpeter.
DRIERS.--Another important division of this first class of centrifugals is that of driers or, as they are variously styled, whizzers, wringers, hydro-extractors. The charge in these is never large in weight compared to a sugar charge, and its initial distribution can be made more symmetrical. The uses of driers are various, such as extracting water from clothes, cloth, silk, yarns, etc. Water may be introduced at the center of the basket from above or below to wash the material before draining. A typical form of drier is shown in Fig. 24. (Pat. Aug. 22, 1876--W.P. Uhlinger.) Baskets have been made removable for use in dyeing establishments, basket and load together going into dyeing vat. Yarn and similar material can be drained by a method analogous to that of hanging it upon sticks in a room and allowing the water to drip off. It is suspended from short sticks, which are held in horizontal layers around the shaft in the basket, and the action is such during the operation as to cause the yarn to stand out in radial lines.
Driers are not materially different from sugar machines. Any of the devices before enumerated for meeting vibrations in the latter may be applied to the former. There is one curious invention which has been applied to driers only (Pat. 322,762--W.H. Tolhurst). See Fig. 25. A convex shaft-supporting step resting on a concave supporting base, with the center of its arc of concavity at the center of the upper universal joint, has been employed, and its movements controlled by springs, but the step was apt to be forced from its support. The drawing shows the improvement on this, which is to give the shaft-supporting step a less radius of curvature.
An interesting form of drier has its own motor, a little steam engine, attached to the frame of the machine. See Fig 24. This of course demands fixed bearings. The engine is very small. One size used is 3"×4". When a higher velocity of basket is required, we have the arrangement in Fig. 26.
MOTORS.--This naturally introduces the subject of motive power. We may have the engine direct acting as above, or the power may be brought on by belting. Fig. 27 shows a drier with pulley for belting. Fig. 28 (W.H. Tolhurst) shows a very common arrangement of belting and also the fast and loose pulleys. When the heaviest part of the engine is so far from the vertical shaft as to overhang the casing on one side, there is apt to be an objectionable tremor. To remedy this, it is suggested to put these heavy parts as near the shaft as possible. It has been suggested also to use the Westinghouse type of engine, although the type shown in Fig. 24 works faultlessly in practice.
One plan (Pat. 346,030), designed to combine the advantages of a direct acting motor and an oscillating shaft, mounts the whole machine, motor and all, on a rocking frame. The spindle is of course in fixed bearings in the frame. However, the plan is not practical.
In driers the direct acting engine has many advantages over the belt. The atmosphere is always very moist about a whizzer, and there are frequently injurious fumes. The belt will be alternately dry and wet, stretched and limp, and wears out rapidly and is liable to sever. In all machines in which the shaft oscillates, if the center of oscillation does not lie in the central plane of the belt, the tension of the latter is not uniform. This affects badly both the belt and the running. A reference to the various figures will show the best position for the pulley.
The greatest difficulty experienced with belting is in getting up speed and stopping. The basket must not be started with a sudden impulse. Its inertia will resist and something must give way. A gradual starting can be obtained by the slipping of the belt at first, but this is expensive. The best plan is to conduct the power through a species of friction clutch--an iron disk between two wooden ones. This has been found to work admirably.
BRAKES.--The first centrifugals had no brakes. They ran until the friction of the bearings was sufficient to stop them. This occasioned, however, rapid wearing and too great a loss of time. The best material for a brake consists of soft wood into which shoe pegs have been driven, and which is thoroughly saturated with oil. The wooden disks referred to just above are of the same construction. The center of oscillation ought to be in the central plane of the brake as well as that of the pulley, but the preference is given to the pulley.
Figs. 15 and 16 (I) give sectional views of a brake for hanging machines. Figs. 19, 20, and 21 give two sections and a view of a brake which can be used on both hanging and standing machines. A very simple form of brake is shown in Figs. 24, 26, and 27 (A), a mere block pressing on the rim of the basket.
OIL AND FAT.--A machine in most respects like a whizzer is used for the "extraction of oil and fat and oily and fatty matters from woolen yarns and fabrics, and such other fibrous material or mixtures of materials as are from their nature affected in color or quality when hydrocarbons are used for the purpose of extracting such oily or fatty matters, and are subsequently removed from the material under treatment by the slow process of admitting steam, or using other means of raising the temperature to the respective boiling points of such hydrocarbons, and so driving them off by evaporation." In the centrifugal method carbon-bisulphide, or some other volatile agent, is admitted and is driven through the material by centrifugal force, when the necessary reactions take place, and is allowed to escape in the form of hydrocarbons. A machine differing only in slight particulars from the above is used for cleansing wool.
LOOSE FIBER.--Another application is the drying of loose fiber. Two distinctive points deserve to be noticed in the centrifugal used for this purpose. An endless chain or belt provided with blades moves the material vertically in the basket, and discharges it over the edge. During its upward course the material is subjected to a shower of water to wash it.
OIL FROM METAL CHIPS.--Very material savings are made in many factories by collecting the metal chips and turnings, coated and mixed with oil, which fall from the various machines, and extracting the oil centrifugally. The separator consists of a chip holder, having an imperforate shell flaring upward and outward from the spindle (in fixed bearings) to which it is attached. When filled, a cover is placed upon it and keyed to the spindle. Between the cover and holder there is a small annular opening through which oil, but not chips, can escape. Fig. 29 (Pat. 225,949--C.F. Roper) is designed (like the greater part of the drawings inserted) to show relative position of parts merely, and not relative _size_. This style of machine can be used for sugar separating (Pat. 345,994--F.P. Sherman) and many other purposes, to which, however, there are other styles more especially adapted.
FILTERERS.--There are two distinct kinds of centrifugal filterers, working on different principles. Petroleum separators (Pat. 217,063) are of the first kind. They are in form in all respects like a sugar machine. The flakes of paraffine, stearine, etc., which are to be extracted, when chilled are very brittle and would be disintegrated upon being hurled against a plain wire gauze and would escape. Even a woven fabric presents too harsh a surface. It is necessary to have a very elastic basket lining of wool, cotton, or other fibrous material. The basket itself may be either wire or perforated, but must have a perfectly smooth bottom.
As the pressure of the liquor upon the filtering medium per unit of surface depends entirely upon its radial depth, mere tubes, connecting a central inlet with an annular compartment, will serve the purpose quite as well as a whole basket. In this style of machine (Pat. 10,457) the filtering material constitutes a wall between two annular compartments. The outer one is connected with a vacuum apparatus.
Filterers of the second kind work on the following principle: If a cylinder be rapidly revolved in a liquid in which solid particles are suspended, the liquid will be drawn into a like rotation and the heavy particles will be thrown to the outer part of the receptacle. If a perforated cylinder is used as stirrer, the purified liquid will escape into it through the perforations and may be conducted away. The impurities, likewise, after falling down the sides of the receptacle, are carried off. The advantages of this method are that no filtering material is needed and the filtering surface is never in contact with anything but pure liquor.
Very fine sawdust is, to a considerable extent, employed in sugar refineries as a filtering medium. By such use the sawdust becomes mixed with sand, fine particles of cane, etc. As sawdust of such fineness is expensive, it is desirable to purify it in order to reuse it. A centrifugal (Pat. 353,775--J.V.V. Booraem) built on the following principle is used for this purpose. It has been observed that by rotating rather _slowly_ small particles of various substances in water, the finer particles will be thrown outward and deposit near the circumference of the vessel, while the heavier and coarser particles will deposit nearer to or at the center, their centrifugal force not being sufficient to carry them out. A mere rod, extending radially in both directions, serves by its rotation to set the water in motion.
Another form of filter of this second kind (Pat. 148,513) has a rotating imperforate basket into which the impure liquor is run. Within and concentric with it is another cylinder whose walls are of some filtering medium. The liquid already partly purified by centrifugal force passes through into the inner cylinder, thus becoming further purified. Centrifugal filters are used also to cleanse gums for varnishes.
HONEY.--The simplest form of honey extractor (Pat. 61,216) consists of a square framework, symmetrical with respect to a vertical spindle. This framework is surrounded by a wire gauze. The combs, after having the heads of the cells cut off, are placed in comb-holders against the wire netting on the four sides, the cells pointing outward. The machine is turned by hand. The honey is hurled against the walls of a receiving case and caught below. But few improvements have been made on this. The latest machines are still hand-driven, as a sufficiently high velocity can be obtained in this manner. In one style the combs are placed upon a floor which rests upon springs. The rotating box is given a slight vertical and horizontal reciprocatory motion, by which the combs are made to grate on the wire gauze sides, breaking the cells and liberating the honey. Thus the labor of cutting the cells is saved. Every comb has two sides, and to present each side in succession to the outside without removing from the basket, several devices have been patented. In some the comb holders are hinged in the corners of the basket, and have an angular motion of ninety degrees. Decreasing the speed is sufficient to swing these. The other side is then emptied by revolving in the opposite direction. In one case each holder has a spindle of its own, connected with the main spindle by gearing and, to present opposite side, turns through 180°. The usual number of sides and hence of comb holders is four, but eight have been used. There are minor differences in details of construction, looking to the most convenient removal and insertion of comb, the reception of the extracted honey in cups, buckets, etc., and the best method of giving rapid rotation, which cannot be touched upon. The product of the operation is white and opaque, but upon heating regains its golden color and transparency.
STARCH.--A centrifugal to separate starch from triturated grain, carried in suspension in water, is as follows. (Pat. 273,127--Müller & Decastro.) The starch water is led to the bottom of a basket, and, as starch is heavier than the gluten with which it is mixed, the former will be immediately compacted against the periphery of the basket, lodging first in the lower corner, the starch and gluten forming two distinct strata. A tube with a cutting edge enters the compacted mass so deeply as to peel off the gluten and part of the starch, which is carried through the tube to another compartment of the basket, just above, where the same operation is performed, and so on. There may be only one compartment, the tube carrying the gluten directly out of the machine. These machines are continuous working, and hence some way must be devised to carry the water off. The inner surface of the water is, as we have seen, a cylinder. When the diameter of this cylinder becomes too small, overflow must be allowed. One plan is to have an overflow opening made in the bottom of the basket in such a way that as the starch wall thickens, the opening recedes toward the center. The starch wall is either lifted out in cakes or put again in suspension by spraying water on it and conducting the mixture off.
A centrifugal (Pat. 74,021) to separate liquids from paints depends on building a wall of paint on the sides of the basket and carrying the liquids off at the center.
A centrifugal (Pat. 310,469) for assorting wood pulp, paper pulp, etc., works by massing the constituents in two or three cylindrical strata, and after action severing and removing these separately.
BREWING.--In brewing, centrifugals are quite useful. After the wort has been boiled with hops, albuminous matters are precipitated by the tannic acid, which must be extracted. Besides these the mixture frequently contains husk, fiber, and gluten. The machine (Pat. 315,876), although quite unique in construction, has the same principle of working as a sugar centrifugal, and need not be described. There is one point, however, which might be noticed--that air is introduced at about the same point as the material, and has an oxidizing and refrigerating effect.
Class I. includes also centrifugals for the following purposes: The removal of must from the grape after crushing, making butter, extracting oils from solid fats, separating the liquid and solid parts of sewerage, drying hides, skins, spent tan and the like, drying coils of wire.
HORIZONTAL CENTRIFUGALS.--Only vertical machines have been and will be dealt with. Horizontal centrifugals, that is, those whose spindles are horizontal have been made, but the great inconvenience of charging and discharging connected with them has occasioned their disuse; though in other respects for liquids they are quite as good as vertical separators. Their underlying theory is practically the same as that hereinbefore discussed.
CLASS II., CREAMERS.--Centrifugals of the second class separate liquids from liquids. There are two main applications in this class--to separate cream from milk and fusel oil from alcoholic liquors. When a liquid is to be separated from a liquid, the receptacle must be imperforate. The components of different specific gravity become arranged in distinct concentric cylindrical strata in the basket, and must be conducted away separately. In creamers the particles of cream must not be broken or subjected to any concussion, as partial churning is caused and the cream will, in consequence, sour more rapidly.
The chief cause of oscillations in machines of this class, where the charge is liquid, is the waves which form on the inner surface. They may be met by allowing a slight overflow over the inner edge of the rim of the basket; or by having either horizontal partitions, or vertical, radial ones, special cases of which will be noticed. Oscillations may also be met in the same manner as in sugar machines, by allowing the revolving parts to revolve about an axis through their common center of gravity. (Pat. 360,342--J. Evans.)
The crudest form of creamer contains a number of bottles, with their necks all directed toward the spindle, filled with milk. The necks, in which the cream collects, are graduated to tell when the operation is complete.