Part 1
NOTES ON THE IROQUOIS:
OR, CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE
STATISTICS, ABORIGINAL HISTORY, ANTIQUITIES AND GENERAL ETHNOLOGY
OF
WESTERN NEW-YORK.
* * * * *
BY HENRY R. SCHOOLCRAFT,
Hon. Mem. of the Royal Society of Northern Antiquaries, Copenhagen; Hon. Mem. of the Royal Geographical Society of London; Vice-President of the American Ethnological Society at New-York; Member of the American Philosophical, of the American Antiquarian, and of the American Geological Societies; Hon. Mem. of the New-York Historical, of the Georgia Historical, and of the Rhode-Island Historical Societies, &c., &c., &c.
* * * * *
NEW-YORK: BARTLETT & WELFORD, ASTOR HOUSE.
1846.
SENATE DOCUMENT, TWENTY-FOUR.
In giving a more permanent form to the original edition of this document, a more convenient reference title has been prefixed to it.
The aboriginal nation, whose statistics and history, past and present, are brought into discussion in the following report, stand out prominently in the foreground of our own history. They have sustained themselves, for more than three centuries and a half, against the intruding and progressive races of Europe. During the period of the planting of the colonies, their military exploits gave them a name and a reputation which are coeval with Europe. These events are intermingled, more or less, with the history of each of the colonies, and impart to them much of their interest. But while we have made an extraordinary progress in population and resources, and gone far to build up a nationality, and commenced a national literature, very little, if any, progress has been made in clearing up and narrowing the boundaries of historical mystery, which shroud the INDIAN PERIOD prior to 1492. This forms, indeed, the true period of American Ethnology.
It was a desideratum in American statistics, that a complete census of one of these primary stocks, who had lived in our neighborhood all this time, and still preserved their nationality, should be taken. This task New-York executed in 1845. It appeared desirable to the agent appointed to carry the act of the legislature, embracing this feature, into effect, that the opportunity should not be lost of making some notes of the kind here indicated; and it is in this feature, indeed, if any thing, in the report now presented, that it aspires to the character of research, though it be intended only to shadow forth outlines to be filled up hereafter.
_New-York, Feb. 7, 1846._
MEMORANDUM OF PAPERS.
Page. Letter from the Secretary of State, laying the result of the census before the Senate, 1
Statistical report, communicating the census returns, 3
Letter transmitting supplemental report on their past and present history, 21
I. HISTORICAL AND ETHNOLOGICAL MINUTES, 25 _a._ Sketch of the Iroquois Groups of Aboriginal Tribes, 25 _b._ Ethnological suggestions, 33 _c._ Indian Cosmogony, 36 _d._ Gleams of their ancient general history, 38
II. ORIGIN AND HISTORY OF THE IROQUOIS, AS A DISTINCT PEOPLE, 41 _a._ Mohawks, 43 _b._ Oneidas and the Oneida stone, (with three engravings,) 46 _c._ Onondagas, (with a figure,) 54 _d._ Cayugas, 57 _e._ Senecas and their origin, 59 _f._ Tuscaroras, and their flight from North Carolina, 64 _g._ Necariages, 69 _h._ St. Regis colony, 70
III. EPOCH AND PRINCIPLES OF THE IROQUOIS LEAGUE, 73 _a._ Considerations, 73 _b._ Era of the confederacy, 73 _c._ Principles of their government and Totemic Bond, 76 _d._ Ancient worship and system of astronomy, 85 _e._ Witchcraft, its theory and practical evils, 87 _f._ Wife’s right to property—limited nature of marriage contract, 88
IV. ARCHÆOLOGY, 91 _a._ Vestiges of an ancient French fort in Lenox, (with a plan,) 93 _b._ Ancient site of the Onondagas at Kasonda, (with a sketch,) 96 _c._ Antiquities of Pompey, Camillus, &c., 103 _d._ Ancient fort of Osco at Auburn, (with a plan,) 106 _e._ Vestiges of an ancient elliptical work at Canandaigua, (with an outline,) 109 _f._ Fort-Hill, Genesee county, (with a plan,) 111 _g._ Rock-citadel of Kienuka, in Niagara county, (with a plan,) 116 _h._ Circular fort at Deoseowa, Erie county, (with an outline,) 120
V. ANCIENT STATE OF INDIAN ART, 125
VI. RELICS OF ABORIGINAL ART IN WESTERN NEW-YORK, 133 Class 1. Nabikoagunä, [medals,] 134 Class 2. Medäekä, [amulets,] 137 Class 3. Attejegunä, [implements of art,] 139 Class 4. Opoagunä, [pipes,] 140 Class 5. Minäce, [beads,] 142 Class 6. Peägä, [wampums,] 143 Class 7. Mudwämina, [jingling dress ornaments,] 143 Class 8. Otoaugunä, [ear jewels,] 144 Class 9. Æs, [shells,] 144 Class 10. Ochalis, [nose jewels,] 145
VII. ORAL TRADITIONS OF THE IROQUOIS, HISTORICAL AND SYMBOLIC, 147 _a._ Ancient shipwreck of a vessel on the coast, 147 _b._ Forays into the Cherokee and Cataba country, 148 _c._ Exploit of Hiadeoni, 150 _d._ Seneca embassy of peace to the Cherokees, and exploit of Awl, 153 _e._ Grave-yard serpent and corn giant 154 _f._ Allusion to the siege of Fort Stanwix and battle of Oriskany, 155 _g._ Defeat of the Kah-Kwahs, 155 _h._ Epoch of the confederacy, 156 _i._ Some passages of their wars with monsters and giants, 156
VIII. TOPICAL INQUIRIES, 163 _a._ Who were the Eries? 164 _b._ Building of the first vessel on the upper lakes, 166 _c._ Who were the Alleghans? 168 _d._ War with the Kah-Kwahs and their retreat down the Allegany, 176
IX. MISCELLANEOUS TRAITS, 181 _a._ Infant Atotarho, 181 _b._ Red Jacket and the Wyandot and Delaware claim to supremacy, 182 _c._ Brant and the Buffalo church, 183 _d._ The county clerk and the wolf scalp, 184 _e._ Specimen of Iroquois picture writing, 132
X. MORAL AND SOCIAL CONDITION AND PROSPECTS, 185
ABSTRACT OF CENSUS RETURNS, 191
DEAF AND DUMB, IDIOTS, LUNATICS AND BLIND, 201
APPENDIX.
Benton, 203
Extracts from author’s private journal, 206
Clark, 233
Cusick, 237
Goodwin, 241
Follett, 243
Dewey, 246
Rockwood, with Tuscarora vocabulary, 250
Bliss, 261
Hall, 263
McMurray, with Mohawk and Cayuga vocabulary, 264
Shearman, with Oneida vocabulary, 278
Walker, 282
Van Schaack, 283
Morgan, 284
STATE OF NEW-YORK.
No. 24.
IN SENATE,
January 22 1846.
COMMUNICATION
From the Secretary of State, transmitting the report of Mr. Schoolcraft, one of the agents appointed to take the census or enumeration of the Indians, &c.
SECRETARY’S OFFICE, } _Albany, January 17th, 1846_.}
Hon. A. GARDINER,
_President of the Senate_:
SIR:
In compliance with the resolution of the Senate of the 15th instant, I transmit herewith a report of one of the agents appointed to take the census or enumeration of the Indians residing upon several of the reservations in the State, and an abstract of all the census returns, taken pursuant to the fifteenth section of the act chapter 140 of the laws of 1845, and of the statistical information required by the act, and also a report relating “to their past and present condition.”
I am, very respectfully, Your obedient servant, N. S. BENTON.
REPORT
Of Mr. Schoolcraft, to the Secretary of State, transmitting the census returns in relation to the Indians.
CENSUS OF THE IROQUOIS.
_New-York, October 31st, 1845._
SIR:
In conformity with your instructions of the 25th June last, I proceeded to the several Iroquois reservations therein named, and I have the honor herewith to transmit to you the census returns for each reservation, numbered from I to VIII, and distinguished by the popular name of each tribe, or canton.
I. The question of the original generic name, by which these tribes were denoted, the relation they bear to the other aboriginal stocks of America, and the probable era of their arrival, and location within the present boundaries of this State, is one, which was naturally suggested by the statistical inquiries entrusted to me. Difficult and uncertain as any thing brought forward on these subjects must necessarily be, it was yet desirable, in giving a view of the present and former condition of the people, that the matter should be glanced at. For, although nothing very satisfactory might be stated, it was still conceived to be well to give some answer to the intelligent inquirer, to the end, that it might, at least, be perceived the subject had not escaped notice.
A tropical climate, ample means of subsistence, and their consequence, a concentrated and fixed population, raised the ancient inhabitants of Mexico, and some other leading nations on the continent, to a state of ease and semi-civilization, which have commanded the surprise and admiration of historians. But it may be said, in truth, that, in their fine physical type, and in their energy of character, and love of independence, no people, among the aboriginal race, have ever exceeded, if any has ever equalled, the Iroquois.
Discoveries made in the settlement of New-York, west of the DE O WAIN STA, or Stanwix Summit, have led to the belief, that there has been an ancient period of occupation of that fertile and expanded portion of the State, which terminated prior to the arrival of the Iroquois. Evidences have not been wanting to denote, that a higher degree of civilization than any of these tribes possessed, had, at a remote period, begun to develope itself in that quarter. But, hitherto, the notices and examinations of the antiquities referred to, although highly creditable to the observers, and abounding in interest, have served rather to entangle, than reveal, the archæological mystery which envelopes them. Some of these antiquarian traits, not appearing to the first settlers to be invested with the importance, as industrial or military vestiges, now attached to them, have been nearly or quite obliterated by the plough. The spade of the builder and excavator has overturned others; and at the rate of increase, which has marked our numbers and industry, since the close of the revolutionary war, little or nothing of this kind will remain, in a perfect state, very long.
To gratify the moral interest belonging to the subject, by full and elaborate plans and descriptions, would require time and means, very different from any at my command the past season; but the topic was one which admitted of incidental attention, while awaiting decisions and obviating objections which some of the tribes urged to the general principles and policy of the census. And while the subject of a full archæological and ethnological survey of the State is left as the appropriate theme of future research, facts and traditions, bearing on these subjects, were obtained and minuted down, at various points.
In availing myself of the liberty extended to me in this particular, by your instructions, I have, in fact, improved every possible means of information. Notes and sketches were taken down from the lips of both white and red men, wherever the matter itself and the trustworthiness of the individual appeared to justify them. Many of the ancient forts, barrows and general places of ancient sepulchre were visited, and of some of them, accurate plans, diagrams or sketches made on the spot, or obtained from other hands. A general interest was manifested in the subject by the citizens of western New-York, wherever it was introduced, and a most ready and obliging disposition evinced, on all hands, to promote the inquiry.
The result of these examinations, and collections made by the wayside, it is my intention to report in the form of _Historical and Ethnological Minutes_, which will be engrossed without loss of time from my original notes. These minutes, when properly arranged and copied, will constitute a document supplementary to the report here offered. It is not to be inferred, however, that they will exhibit a compact and full digest of Iroquois history. Attention has rather been given to the lapses in their history, and to the supplying of data for its future construction. Little more has ever been thought of. This part of my investigations will be communicated, therefore, as a contribution to the historical materials of the State, touching its aborigines. Satisfied that the New-York public regard the subject with decided approbation, and well aware of the munificence which has marked the State policy, with regard to the acquisition of historical documents from abroad, I may, I trust, be permitted to indulge the hope, that the Legislature will likewise extend its countenance to this portion of the labor which, as the State Marshal under the act, I have performed.
II. The present being the first time[1] that a formal and full census of a nation or tribe of Indians has been called for, with their industrial efforts, by any American or European government exercising authority on this continent, the principles and policy of the measure presented a novel question to the Iroquois, and led to extended discussions. As these discussions, in which the speakers evinced no little aptitude, bring out some characteristic traits of the people, it may be pertinent, and not out of place here, briefly to advert to them.
[1] It forms no contradiction to the precise terms of this remark, that the Legislature of Virginia directed the numbering of the Powhatanic tribes, within its boundaries, in 1788. Vide Jefferson’s Notes on Virginia.
As a general fact, the policy of a census, and its beneficial bearings on society, were not understood or admitted.[2] It seemed to these ancient cantons to be an infringement on that independence of condition which they still claim and ardently cherish. In truth, of all subjects upon which these people have been called on to think and act, during our proximity to them of two or three centuries, that of political economy is decidedly the most foreign and least known to them, or appreciated by them, and the census movement was, consequently, the theme of no small number of suspicions and cavils and objections. Without any certain or generally fixed grounds of objection, it was yet the object of a fixed but changing opposition. If I might judge, from the scope of remarks made both in and out of council, they regarded it as the introduction of a Saxon feature into their institutions, which, like a lever, by some process not apparent to them, was designed, in its ultimate effects, to uplift and overturn them. And no small degree of pith and irony was put forth against it by the eloquent respondents who stood in the official attitude of their ancient orators. Everywhere, the tribes exalted the question into one of national moment. Grave and dignified sachems assembled in formal councils, and indulged in long and fluent harangues to their people, as if the very foundations of their ancient confederacy were about to be overturned by an innovating spirit of political arithmetic and utilitarianism. When their true views were made known, however, after many days and adjourned councils, I found there was less objection to the mere numbering of their tribes and families, than the [to them] scrutinizing demand, which the act called for, into their agricultural products, and the results of their industry. Pride also had some weight in the matter. “We have but little,” said one of the chiefs, in a speech in council, “to exhibit. Those who have yielded their assent, have their barns well stored, and need not blush when you call.”
[2] To this remark, the Tuscaroras, who met the subject at once, in a frank and confidential manner, and the Onondagas, who appeared to be governed therein by the counsels of a single educated chief, form exceptions.
Another topic mixed itself with the consideration of the census, and made some of the chiefs distrustful of it. I allude to the long disturbed state of their land question, and the treaty of compromise which has recently been made with the Ogden Company, by which the reversionary right to the fee simple of two of their reservations has been modified. In this compromise, the Tonewandas, a considerable sub-tribe or departmental band of Senecas, did not unite; yet the reservation which they occupy is one of the tracts to be given up. They opposed the census, from the mere fear of committing themselves on this prior question, in some way, not very well understood by them, and certainly not well made out by their speakers. It is known that for many years, the general question of ceding their reservations, under the provisions of an early treaty of the State with the Six Nations, had divided the Senecas into two parties. A discussion which has extended through nearly half a century, in which Red Jacket had exhibited all his eloquence, had sharpened the national acumen in negotiation, and produced a peculiar sensitiveness and, suspicion of motive, whenever, in latter times, the slightest question of interest or policy has been introduced into their councils. This spirit evinced itself in the very outset of my visit, on announcing to certain bands the requirements of the census act. Some of them were, moreover, strongly disposed to view it as the preliminary step, on the part of the Legislature, to taxation. To be taxed, is an idea which the Iroquois regard with horror. They had themselves, in ancient days, put nations under tribute, and understood very well the import of a State tax upon their property.
“Why,” said the Tonewanda chief, Deonehogawa, (called John Blacksmith,) “why is this census asked for, at this time, when we are in a straitened position with respect to our reservation? Or if it is important to you or us, why was it not called for before? If you do not wish to obtain facts about our lands and cattle, to tax us, what is the object of the census? What is to be done with the information after you take it to Governor Wright, at Skenectati?”[3]
[3] The aborigines are very tenacious of their geographical names. This ancient name of the seat of government I found to be used, on every occasion, among the Senecas, when it was necessary to allude to Albany. Its transference on the conquest of the province, in 1664, to the banks of the Mohawk, in lieu of the aboriginal name of _Onigarawantel_, never received, at least, their sanction.
Hoeyanehqui, or Sky-carrier, a Buffalo chief, in answer to a question as to their views of the abstract right of the State to tax the tribes, evaded a direct issue, but assuming the ground of policy, compared the Iroquois to a sick man, and said, “that he did not believe the State would oppress one thus weak.”
Kaweaka, a Tuscarora chief of intelligence, speaking the English language very well, in which he is called William Mount-Pleasant, gave a proof, in yielding to the measure promptly, that he had not failed to profit by the use of letters. “We know our own rights. Should the Legislature attempt to tax us, our protection is in the Constitution of the United States, which forbids it.” This is the first appeal, it is thought, ever made by an Iroquois to this instrument. The clause referred to, relates however, wholly to representation in Congress, [Vide Art. 1, Sec. II, 2d.] from the privileges of which it excludes “Indians not taxed,” clearly implying that such persons might be represented in that body if “taxed.” Civilization and taxation appear to be inseparable.
III. Having detailed the steps taken in procuring the census, it only remains to subjoin a few remarks, which I beg leave to add, on the general features of the statistics and the results of their agriculture upon their condition and prospects.