Newspaper Reporting and Correspondence A Manual for Reporters, Correspondents, and Students of Newspaper Writing

Part 7

Chapter 73,574 wordsPublic domain

Thus, while telling the story almost in its logical order, we have picked out the high spots of interest and crowded them to the beginning. Our readers will get the facts just about as fast as they wish to read them and in the order in which they wish them. Our story may be run in nine paragraphs or even more; or the editor may slash off anything after the fourth paragraph without taking away any of the essential facts of the fire. This method of telling would fulfill all the requirements of an ideal news story. A similar outline of the facts that any story must present will often help a reporter to tell his story as it should be told. After listing the details he may number them in their order of importance and check them off as he has told them.

* * * * *

This idea of throwing the emphasis and interest to the beginning applies to the individual paragraphs and sentences of the story, as well. Each paragraph must begin strongly and display its most interesting content in the first line. The emphatic part of each sentence should be the beginning. A glance at any newspaper column shows why this is necessary.

The body of a news story is the place for the reporter's skill and style. He is given all the liberties of ordinary narration and should make the most of every word. His individual style comes into play here. If the interest can be increased by a bit of dialogue the reporter may put it in. If the facts can be presented more effectively by means of direct quotation, the words of any one whom the reporter has interviewed may be of interest. However, these things must not be overworked because every trick of writing loses its effectiveness when it is overworked.

Dialogue used only to give facts which might be told more clearly in simple direct form should seldom be used. Dialogue in a news story is used only to color the story and not to reproduce the interviews by which the facts were obtained. In gathering the facts of a story it is sometimes necessary to interview a number of people, but these interviews should not be quoted in the resulting story. Many a green reporter tries to give his story character by telling what the policeman on the corner, the janitor, and a small boy in the street told him about the incident. He succeeds only in dragging out the length of his story and confusing the reader. After all, the purpose of a newspaper is to give facts--and the clearer and the more direct the method the better will be the result.

In striving for clearness and interest a reporter must remember that one of his greatest assets is concreteness of expression. Of all forms of composition newspaper writing possesses probably the greatest opportunity for definiteness. Facts and events are its one concern; theories and abstractions are beyond its range. Hence the more definite and concrete its presentation of facts, the better will be its effect. The reporter should never generalize or present his statements hazily and uncertainly--a fact is a fact and must be presented as such. He must try to avoid such expressions as "several," "many," "a few"--it is usually possible to give the exact number. He must continually ask himself "how many?" "what kind?" "exactly when?" "exactly what?" Expressions like "about a dozen," "about thirty years old," "about a week ago," "about a block away," are never so effective as the exact facts and figures. Definite concrete details make a news story real and vivid. The real reporter of news is the one who can see a thing clearly and with every detail and present it as clearly and distinctly.

VIII

OTHER NEWS STORIES

The fire story is obviously not the only news story that is printed in a daily newspaper, but a study of its form gives us a working knowledge of the writing of other news stories. The fire story is probably the commonest news story, and it is by far the easiest story to handle, for its form has become somewhat standardized. We know just exactly what our readers want to know about each fire, and within certain limits all fires, as well as the reports of them, are very much alike. There is seldom more than one fact or incident that makes one fire different from another and that fact we always seize as the feature of our report. However, the fire story has been taken only as typical of other news stories. Now we are ready to study the others, using the fire story as our model in writing the others.

There is a vast number of other stories that we must be able to write, and they lack the convenient uniformity that fires have. Not only does every story have a different feature, but it is concerned with a different kind of happening. One assignment may call for the report of an explosion, another the report of a business transaction, and another a murder. In each one we have to get the facts and choose the most striking fact as our feature. Never can we resort to the simple beginning "Fire destroyed," but we must find a different beginning for each assignment.

Just as in the fire story, the lead of any news story is the most important part. It must begin with the most striking part of the event and answer the reader's _Where?_ _When?_ _How?_ _Why?_ and _Who?_ concerning it. All the rules that apply to the fire lead apply to the lead of any story.

It would be impossible to classify all the news stories that a newspaper must print. The very zest of reporting comes from the changing variety of the work; no two assignments are ever exactly alike--if they were only one would be worth printing. Newspapers themselves make no attempt to classify the ordinary run of news or to work out a systematic division of labor; a reporter may be called upon to cover a fire, a political meeting, a murder, a business story, all in the same day. Each one is simply a story and must be covered in the same way that all the rest are covered--by many interviews for facts. For our study it may be well to divide news stories into a few large groups. The groups overlap and are not entirely distinct, but the stories in each group have some one thing in common that may aid us in learning how to write them. At most, the list is only a very incomplete summary of the more important kinds of news stories and is intended to be merely a suggestive way of supplying the student with necessary practice.

=1. Accidents.=--Accident stories may be anything from a sprained ankle to a disastrous railroad wreck, but they all depend upon one element for their interest. They are all printed because people in general are interested in the injuries and deaths of other people--physical calamity is the common ground in all these stories.

The number of possible accidents is infinite, but there are some common types that recur most often. Among these are: railroad, trolley, railroad crossing accidents; runaways; electrocutions; explosions; collapse of buildings; marine disasters; cave-in accidents; elevator, automobile, aviation accidents.

The feature of any accident story is always, of course, the thing that made the story worth printing, and that is usually the human life element. The feature of an accident story is almost always the number of dead and injured. Most reports of railroad wrecks begin with "Ten persons were killed and seventeen were injured in a wreck, etc." The same is true of any accident story; if more than one person is killed it is usually safe to begin with the number of fatalities. In this connection it may be noted that the death of railroad employees seldom makes a story worth printing; they may be included in the total number, but if no passengers are killed, fatalities among trainmen seldom give a story any news value.

Accident stories of course have many other possible features; newspapers report many accidents in which no one is killed. In that case some other element gives the story news value and that element must be played up as the feature. Perhaps it is the manner in which the accident happened or the manner in which a person was killed or injured, as in an automobile accident. The cause of the accident may be the most interesting part of the story: train-wreckers or a broken rail in a railroad wreck, or the cause of an explosion. Very often an accident is reported simply because some well-known person was connected with it in some way; the name then becomes the feature and comes into the first line. A story may be worth printing simply because of the unusual manner of rescue; such a feature is often played up in stories of marine accidents, cave-ins, etc. Not infrequently some of the unusual attendant circumstances give a story news value: e.g., a policeman dragged from his horse and run over by an automobile while he is trying to stop a runaway.

Here are some accident stories from the newspapers:

Fatalities:

| Six men were killed and a dozen | |seriously injured early to-day by an | |outbound Panhandle passenger train | |crashing into the rear end of a Chicago, | |Milwaukee and St. Paul stock train at | |Twelfth and Rockwell streets.--_Chicago | |Record-Herald._ |

Manner:

| Run down by her own automobile, which | |she was cranking, at First and G streets,| |northwest, Dr. Alma C. Arnold, a | |chiropractic physician, 825 Fifteenth | |street, northwest, was forced against the| |wheel of a passing wagon and seriously | |injured this morning.--_Washington | |Times._ |

Cause:

| Over-balanced by a granite stone | |weighing four tons, the entire cornice | |over the west portico of the new west | |wing of the capitol fell to the ground | |this afternoon, carrying with it Daniel | |Logan, foreman for the Woodbury Granite | |Company.--_Madison Democrat._ |

Attendant Circumstances:

| With a blast that shook the entire city| |and was believed by many to be an | |earthquake, three boilers in the new | |engine house of the Pabst brewery on | |Tenth street, between Chestnut street and| |Cold Spring avenue, exploded at about 4 | |o'clock this morning.--_Milwaukee Free | |Press._ |

=2. Robberies.=--Another large class of news stories is concerned with robberies of various kinds. Unfortunately for the reporter, very few robberies are alike; beyond the common ground of the interest in the amount stolen and the cleverness of the robber's work, there is seldom any one thing that may be looked for as the feature of a robbery story. The reporter must decide what in the story makes it worth printing.

Robbery stories may include anything from petty thievery to bank defaulting. Some of the possibilities are horse and automobile stealing, burglary, hold-ups, train and street-car robbery, embezzlement, fraud, kidnapping, safe-cracking, shop and bank robbery. It is well for the reporter who has to cover a story of this class to acquaint himself with the distinctions that characterize the various kinds of robbery and the various names applied to the people who commit this sort of crime: e.g., robber, thief, bandit, burglar, hold-up man, thug, embezzler, defaulter, safe-cracker, pick-pocket.

In general the chief interest in robbery stories is in the result of the work--the amount taken--usually accompanied by a term to designate the sort of robbery. Just how the crime was committed is often the feature, as in a train robbery or a clever case of fraud. If the victim or victims are at all well known their names may become the most interesting thing in the story--or even the name of a well-known criminal or band of robbers. In some stories, especially if another paper has already covered the story, the pursuit or capture of the criminals is often interesting; the stories of bank robberies often begin in this way. Other attendant circumstances, such as the number of persons who witnessed the crime, may be the feature. In hold-ups, burglaries, and crimes of that sort, the death or wounding of the victim is often played up. Sometimes the reason for the crime, as in a kidnapping case, is of great significance. In the case of a robbery of a bank or any other institution which depends upon credit for its business, the story usually begins with, or at least mentions near the beginning, the present condition of the robbed institution. It is safe to say that in no case is the name of the criminal, the manner of his arrest (if it is not unusual), the police station to which he was taken, or the charge preferred against him worth a place in the lead.

Some robbery stories from the daily press:

Amount taken:

| Furs worth $40,000 were stolen in the | |early hours of yesterday morning within a| |stone's throw of Madison Square. | |Apparently a gang in which there was a | |woman expert in choosing only the best | |furs carried off the costly skins, | |etc.--_New York World._ |

Manner of hold-up:

| Seized by thugs in broad daylight as he| |was crossing the railroad tracks at the | |foot of First avenue east, Fred Butzer, a| |stonemason of Butler, Minn., was thrown | |to the ground, a gag placed in his mouth,| |his pockets were rifled of $36.--_Duluth | |News-Tribune._ |

Unusual sort of pickpocket:

| A young man in evening dress, who was | |going down into the subway station at | |Times Square with the theater crowd that | |filled the entrance just outside of the | |Hotel Knickerbocker early last night, | |paused, knocked a woman under the chin | |and took away her silver chatelaine purse| |containing $20 as deftly as he might have| |flicked the ash off his cigarette. Then | |he disappeared.--_New York Times._ |

Unusual thieves:

| Two girl thieves not more than twelve | |years old and small in stature for their | |age have been operating with great | |success in the different stores in the | |neighborhood of Amsterdam avenue and | |Seventy-ninth street. Five or six thefts,| |etc.--_New York Telegram._ |

Pursuit and capture:

| After a chase along Forty-second street| |and up the steps of the Hotel Manhattan, | |a woman, who said she was Sadie Brown, | |thirty-three years old, of No. 215 West | |Forty-sixth street, was arrested early | |today on suspicion of having picked the | |pocket of a man at, etc.--_New York | |Telegram._ |

Present conditions of robbed bank (second paragraph of an embezzlement story):

| Banking Commissioner Watkins this | |afternoon declared that he found the bank| |perfectly sound, that all commercial | |paper was found intact, that none of the | |accounts have been juggled and that no | |erasures of any kind were | |discovered.--_Philadelphia Inquirer._ |

Unusual sort of burglar:

| Wearing a Salvation Army uniform, a | |burglar was caught early yesterday in the| |home of Walter Katte, a vice-president of| |the New York Central railroad, at | |Irvington-on-the-Hudson.--_New York | |World._ |

=3. Murder.=--The reports of crimes of this sort can hardly be classified, for there are so many things that may be worth featuring in any murder case. The story itself is usually of such importance that the mere fact that a murder has been committed gives it news value even if there is nothing unusual in the crime--just as in the case of a featureless fire story that begins with "Fire." The handling of a crime depends upon the character and circumstances; the reporter must weigh the facts in each case for himself. However, we usually find a feature in the number of persons murdered, the manner in which the crime was committed, the name of the victim, if he or she is well known, the reason for the deed, or in some of the many attendant circumstances, such as arrest, pursuit, etc. One rule must always be followed in the reporting of a murder story: the reporter must confine himself to the necessary facts and omit as many of the gruesome details as possible. He must tell it in a cold, hard-hearted way without elaboration, for the story in itself is gruesome enough. Just as soon as a murder story begins to expand upon shocking details it becomes the worst sort of a yellow story.

Examples of murder stories from the newspapers:

Manner:

| After crushing in the head of his | |superior officer with an axe, James | |Layton, boatswain of the Liverpool | |sailing ship Colony, refused to submit to| |arrest, and, still waving the bloody | |weapon, committed suicide by jumping into| |the sea.--_New York Mail._ |

Motive:

| In revenge for a beating he received | |the day before, Gaetona Ambrifi yesterday| |shot and instantly killed Frank | |Ricciliano, a sub-section foreman on the | |Pennsylvania Railroad, while they were | |working on the roadbed near Peddle | |street, Newark.--_New York Sun._ |

Prominent name:

| Mayor William J. Gaynor of New York | |City was shot and seriously, perhaps | |fatally, wounded on board the steamer | |Kaiser Wilhelm der Grosse at 9:30 as he | |was sailing for Europe. |

Resulting pursuit:

| The police of Brooklyn have another | |murder mystery to unravel through the | |finding early today of the body of Peter | |Barilla on Lincoln road, near Nostrand | |avenue, Flatbush. There were two bullet | |wounds in the body and four stab wounds | |in the back.--_Brooklyn Eagle._ |

Attendant circumstances:

| A hundred or more persons who were | |about to take trains witnessed the | |shooting to death of a Jersey City | |business man in the Pennsylvania Railroad| |station there this afternoon.--_New York | |Mail._ |

=4. Suicide.=--What is true of murder stories is also true of suicide. Each individual case has an unusual feature of its own. We ordinarily find a good beginning in the manner of the suicide, the name of the person who has killed himself if he is well known, the reason for the act, or some one of the attendant circumstances--often the manner of resuscitation if the crime is unsuccessful. For some unexplained reason many papers do not print accounts of ordinary suicides, except when the individual is prominent. At any rate the story must be told without gruesome details and as briefly as possible.

Examples from the press:

Name:

| William L. Murray of Rockview avenue, | |North Plainfield, paying teller of the | |Empire Trust Company of New York, | |committed suicide at Scotch Plains early | |this afternoon by shooting himself in the| |head. No reason is assigned for the | |act.--_New York Sun._ |

Motive:

| Driven insane by continued brooding | |over ill health, Miss Ada Emerson, a | |former teacher in the Beloit city | |schools, killed herself in a crowded | |interurban car Saturday afternoon by | |slashing her throat with a | |razor.--_Beloit Free Press._ |

Here the manner is the feature, but it is not played up in the first line because it is too horrible.

=5. Big Stories.=--The big stories of catastrophes are usually handled on a large scale--played up, as the newspaper men say. The story in itself is of sufficient importance to make it unnecessary to play up any single feature of the story. However, the reporter, in looking for a good beginning, often finds it in the most startling fact in the story. If he is reporting a riot he usually begins with the number of killed or injured, the amount of property destroyed, the character of the riot, or the cause, as in this example:

| In an effort to bring about the | |reinstatement of one of their number who | |had been discharged for non-unionism, a | |hundred or more journeymen bakers wrecked| |the bakeshop of Pincus Jacobs, at No. | |1571 Lexington avenue, early this | |morning.--_New York Evening Post._ |

In the case of a storm the human life element is of greatest importance, then the damage to property, and last, the peculiar circumstances. For example:

| CLEVELAND, Dec. 11.--Fifty-nine lives | |were the cost of a storm which passed | |over Lake Erie Wednesday night and | |Thursday, and more than $1,000,000 worth | |of vessel property was destroyed.--_New | |York Evening Post._ |

If the story is concerned with a flood the human-life element is first, then the damage, the cause, the freaks of the flood, or the present situation. For example:

| PARKERSBURG, W. Va., March 10.--Three | |persons are known to have perished in a | |flood which swept down upon the city on | |Friday when two water reservoirs on | |Prospect Hill burst without warning. | |Forty houses were destroyed and many | |persons are missing. The property damage | |will be nearly $500,000. |

=6. Police Court News.=--The ordinary run of police court news is in a class by itself. Usually the only news value in the story depends upon some unusual incident or circumstance that attracts the attention of the reporter. This is of course the source of many of the stories of crime, mentioned before, but many stories turn up at the police courts which are not concerned with crime, although in some cases they are concerned with criminals. In this field of reporting there are many opportunities for the human-interest story which will be taken up in a later chapter. When the incident is reported in an ordinary news story the feature is usually in some attendant circumstance and the story might well be classed with one of the above groups. Here are two examples from the daily press:

| Because he did not have sufficient | |money to buy flowers for his sweetheart, | |Henry Trupke, aged 21 years, forged a | |check for $22.50 on a grocer, J. | |Sieberlich, 781 Third street, and after a| |week's chase was caught last night as he | |got off a Wisconsin Central | |train.--_Milwaukee Sentinel._ |