Part 1

BOOKS AND BIDDERS

BOOKS AND BIDDERS

THE ADVENTURES OF A BIBLIOPHILE

BY

A. S. W. ROSENBACH

WITH ILLUSTRATIONS

BOSTON LITTLE, BROWN, AND COMPANY 1927

_Copyright, 1927_, BY A. S. W. ROSENBACH

_All rights reserved_

Published November, 1927 Reprinted November, 1927

THE ATLANTIC MONTHLY PRESS PUBLICATIONS ARE PUBLISHED BY LITTLE, BROWN, AND COMPANY IN ASSOCIATION WITH THE ATLANTIC MONTHLY COMPANY

PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA */

TO PHILIP H. ROSENBACH

FOREWORD

It is a pleasant duty to record my appreciation of the assistance rendered me in the writing of these articles by Miss Avery Strakosch (Mrs. W. K. Denham). It was she who, at the suggestion of the editors of the _Saturday Evening Post_, persuaded me to dictate the series of eight articles that appeared in the _Post_ in the first part of 1927. The ninth was published in the _Atlantic Monthly_ in October 1927.

I cannot tell how much I am indebted to her, not only for the form of the articles, but for a friendship that began with the first article and will continue, I trust, long after the last ceases to be read.

A. S. W. R.

CONTENTS

PAGE

I TALKING OF OLD BOOKS 3

II A MILLION DOLLAR BOOKSHELF 35

III SOLD TO DR. R! 68

IV SOME LITERARY FORGERIES 98

V AMONG OLD MANUSCRIPTS 134

VI AMERICAN CHILDREN’S BOOKS 179

VII OLD BIBLES 210

VIII WHY AMERICA BUYS ENGLAND’S BOOKS 243

IX THE COLLECTOR’S BEST BET 264

INDEX 301

ILLUSTRATIONS

PAGE OF THE GUTENBERG BIBLE, SHOWING THE TEN COMMANDMENTS _Frontispiece_

MOSES POLOCK IN HIS BOOKSHOP 6

THE INFANT BIBLIOPHILE 10

STAN V. HENKELS 12

MOSES POLOCK 18

GROLIER BINDING 22

ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF KEATS’S FAMOUS SONNET TO HAYDON 41

FROM A LETTER BY SHELLEY SPEAKING OF KEATS 42

BOOKROOM AT 1320 WALNUT STREET, PHILADELPHIA 44

A. EDWARD NEWTON 46

LETTER OF DR. SAMUEL JOHNSON TO DAVID GARRICK 48

BOOKROOM AT 273 MADISON AVENUE, NEW YORK 56

PAGE FROM ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF CHARLES LAMB’S “THE TRIUMPH OF THE WHALE” 62

PAGE FROM ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF HANDEL’S “MESSIAH” 69

PAGE FROM ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF WAGNER’S “DIE MEISTERSINGER” 73

BOOK AUCTION AT THE ANDERSON GALLERIES, NEW YORK 76

THOMAS E. KIRBY ON THE ROSTRUM 80

“THE BIBLIO-FIENDS”: DRAWING BY OLIVER HERFORD FOR DR. ROSENBACH’S “UNPUBLISHABLE MEMOIRS” 82

SOTHEBY’S AUCTION ROOM IN LONDON 84

SHAKESPEARE WINDOW AT 1320 WALNUT STREET, PHILADELPHIA 86

ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF OSCAR WILDE’S SONNET “ON THE SALE BY AUCTION OF KEATS’ LOVE LETTERS” 94

CHRISTOPHER MORLEY 94

LETTER OF KEATS TO FANNY BRAWNE 96

LAST PAGE OF LETTER WRITTEN BY CERVANTES 101

ORIGINAL DRAWING BY DAUMIER OF DON QUIXOTE 102

FROM A LETTER IN THE AUTOGRAPH OF GEORGE WASHINGTON 106

PAGE FROM A LETTER OF THACKERAY TO MRS. BROOKFIELD 110

PAGE FROM ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF OSCAR WILDE’S “SALOMÉ” 113

DEDICATION OF OSCAR WILDE’S “THE SPHINX” TO MRS. PATRICK CAMPBELL 115

FORGERY OF SHAKESPEARE MANUSCRIPT BY WILLIAM HENRY IRELAND 123

BOOK BELONGING TO THE LORD CHAMBERLAIN, OF WHOSE COMPANY SHAKESPEARE WAS A MEMBER 126

LETTER OF FRANKLIN FROM PHILADELPHIA, 1775 135

PAGE OF FRANKLIN’S WORK BOOK 138

PAGE FROM ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF CONRAD’S “VICTORY” 144

PAGE FROM ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF CONRAD’S “LORD JIM” 145

ONLY UNCUT SHAKESPEARE QUARTO KNOWN 147

PRESENTATION INSCRIPTION TO ELIZABETH BOYLE IN “THE FAERIE QUEENE,” IN THE AUTOGRAPH OF EDMUND SPENSER 150

ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF WALT WHITMAN’S “BY EMERSON’S GRAVE” 152

PAGE FROM MANUSCRIPT OF DICKENS’S “PICKWICK PAPERS” 156

OWEN D. YOUNG 158

DICKENS’S RHYME TO MR. HICKS, PREFIXED TO THE MANUSCRIPT OF “PICKWICK PAPERS” 159

LAST LETTER WRITTEN BY CHARLES DICKENS 160

“THE DYING CLOWN”: ORIGINAL DRAWING BY ROBERT SEYMOUR FOR DICKENS’S “PICKWICK PAPERS” 160

ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF ROBERT BURNS’S POEM “BANNOCKBURN” 162

VAULT AT 273 MADISON AVENUE, NEW YORK 164

PAGE FROM ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF MARK TWAIN’S “TOM SAWYER ABROAD” 165

LETTER OF POE SUBMITTING “EPIMANES” TO THE “NEW ENGLAND MAGAZINE,” WITH PART OF MANUSCRIPT 169

PAGE FROM ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF JOYCE’S “ULYSSES” 171

STANZAS FROM ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF “THE RUBÁIYÁT OF OMAR KHAYYÁM,” BY EDWARD FITZGERALD 175

MANUSCRIPT TITLE PAGE OF HAWTHORNE’S “WONDER BOOK” 180

TITLE PAGE OF “SPIRITUAL MILK FOR BOSTON BABES” 188

WILBERFORCE EAMES 192

TITLE OF “THE GLASS OF WHISKEY” 193

TWO PAGES FROM “THE INFANT’S GRAMMAR” 200

TITLE PAGE OF “THE UNCLE’S PRESENT” 204

PAGE FROM “PETER PIPER’S PRACTICAL PRINCIPLES OF PLAIN AND PERFECT PRONUNCIATION” 208

FIRST PAGE OF CICERO, “DE OFFICIIS,” PRINTED ON VELLUM, MAINZ, 1465 216

BELLE DA COSTA GREENE 218

LEAF FROM AN ENGLISH BIBLICAL MANUSCRIPT OF THE NINTH CENTURY 222

CARVED AND POLYCHROMED WOODEN BINDING OF THE LIESBORN GOSPELS 224

LEAF FROM BLOCK BOOK, FIFTEENTH CENTURY 227

SPECIAL DEDICATION PAGE TO SIXTUS IV, OF JENSON’S BIBLE 232

WOODCUT, “JUDITH AND HOLOFERNES,” FROM CAXTON’S “GOLDEN LEGEND” 233

“JACK JUGGLER,” 1555--THE ONLY COPY KNOWN 247

PAGE OF THE ORIGINAL MANUSCRIPT OF WHITE’S “NATURAL HISTORY OF SELBORNE” 251

PAGE FROM A FOURTEENTH-CENTURY MANUSCRIPT OF THOMAS OCCLEVE’S “POEMS,” SHOWING A PORTRAIT OF CHAUCER 252

HENRY E. HUNTINGTON 254

A CHAUCER MANUSCRIPT IN ORIGINAL BINDING 256

LETTER SIGNED WITH INITIALS OF GEORGE (BEAU) BRUMMELL 258

THE ENGLISH LIBRARY IN DR. ROSENBACH’S HOME 260

MANUSCRIPT OF ARNOLD BENNETT’S UNPUBLISHED PLAY 262

TEA-SHIP BROADSIDE 266

TANKARD PRESENTED TO GEORGE WASHINGTON BY THE REVEREND DR. GREEN 268

ENGRAVED TITLE OF CAPTAIN JOHN SMITH’S “HISTORY OF VIRGINIA” 278

FIRST MAP OF NEW YORK CITY ENGRAVED IN AMERICA 282

GEORGE WASHINGTON’S COPY OF “PROCEEDINGS OF THE CONVENTION” 285

LETTER SIGNED BY BUTTON GWINNETT, BOUGHT FOR $51,000 286

GRANT’S TELEGRAM TO STANTON ANNOUNCING THE SURRENDER OF LEE 298

BOOKS AND BIDDERS

I

TALKING OF OLD BOOKS

“Genius?” The tall old man with the fan-shaped beard looked eagerly at his companion, then settled back more heavily against the rows and rows of old books lining the walls to the ceiling on all sides of the room. “Of course Edgar was a genius, but in spite of being a gambler and a drunkard--in spite of it, I tell you!”

The other, a thin man of lesser years, his long, inquiring face meditative in the twilight, nodded.

“You are right,” he agreed. “But what difference did it make? The only question is, would ‘The Raven’ have been any greater without his gambling and drinking? I doubt it.”

The argument was on, and my uncle, Moses Polock, would lean forward now and again, waving his coatless arms--he handled books easier in shirt sleeves--in an effort to gain a point. His peculiarly young and penetrating blue eyes glistened. Opposite, George P. Philes, a noted editor and book collector, twirled a gray moustache and goatee while balancing in a tilted chair, listening calmly, and patiently relighting a half-smoked cigar which went out often as the verbal heat increased.

I would watch these two, dazed with their heated words concerning authors and their works; hear them make bookish prophecies, most of which came true. A favorite subject was their neurotic friend, Edgar Allan Poe. Both had befriended this singularly unfortunate and great writer, and each had certain contentions to make which led through the fire of argument to the cooler and more even discussion of reminiscences. But they did agree that it would take less than fifty years after Poe’s death to make first editions of his works the most valuable of all American authors.

It was in 1885, when I was nine years old, that I first felt the haunting atmosphere of Uncle Moses’ bookshop on the second floor of the bulging, red-brick building on Commerce Street in old Philadelphia. At that age I could hardly realize, spellbound as I was, the full quality of mystery and intangible beauty which becomes a part of the atmosphere wherever fine books are brought together; for here was something which called to me each afternoon, just as the wharves, the water, and the ships drew other boys who were delighted to get away from books the moment school was out. Whatever it was,--some glibly speak of it as bibliomania,--it entered my bones then, and has grown out of all proportion ever since. The long walk from the bookshop to my home in the twilight, the moon, just coming up, throwing long shadows across the white slab of Franklin’s grave which I had to pass, was sometimes difficult; but as I grew older I learned to shut my eyes against imaginary fears and, in a valiant effort to be brave, hurried past darkened corners and abysmal alleyways, inventing a game by which I tried to visualize the only touches of color in Uncle Moses’ musty, dusty shop--occasional brilliantly bound volumes. Running along, I also cross-examined myself on quotations and dates from books and manuscripts through which I had prowled earlier in the day, unwittingly developing a memory which was often to stand me in good stead.

My uncle’s appreciation of books showed itself long before he took over the publishing and bookselling business established in Philadelphia in 1780, just before the close of the Revolution. Throughout his youth books had been dear to him, and his father, noting this, encouraged him to keep together the volumes he prized most. Yet he gained local attention, not as a book collector but as a publisher, when with a certain amount of initiative he brought out the works of the first American novelist, Charles Brockden Brown. But I early had my suspicions of him as a publisher. It seemed to me that he used the publishing business as a literary cat’s-paw by which he might conceal his real interest and love--searching for, finding, and treasuring rare books.

After all, if one is in a trade, certain expectations are held by the public; and the older Uncle Moses grew the less willing he became to meet these expectations. To publish books and sell them was one phase; but to collect, and then to sell, he considered a different and entirely personal affair. A poor young man, Uncle Moses had acquired the business in an almost magical manner. Jacob Johnson, the original founder, began by publishing children’s books only. But in 1800 he decided to branch out, and took a partner, Benjamin Warner. Fifteen years later the firm was sold out to McCarty and Davis. After several successful years McCarty retired, and it was then that Moses Polock was employed as a clerk. They had spread out and were now publishing all sorts of books. Davis became very fond of his clerk, and when he died, in 1851, left him sufficient money in his will to purchase the business for himself. Luck was evidently with my uncle, for he made a great deal of money in publishing Lindley Murray’s Grammar and other schoolbooks of the time.

First as a publishing house and bookstore combined, Uncle Moses’ shop became a meeting place for publishers and writers. Here it was that the ill-fed Poe came in 1835 to talk modestly of his writings and hopes.

Such men as James Fenimore Cooper, William Cullen Bryant, Noah Webster, and Herman Melville might be seen going up or coming down the narrow staircase leading to the second floor. George Bancroft, the historian, came, too, and Eaton, who wrote the Life of Jackson; George H. Boker, a distinguished Philadelphia poet, Charles Godfrey Leland, of Hans Breitmann Ballads note, and Donald G. Mitchell, who wrote as Ik. Marvel, and many others--they found their way along the uneven brick sidewalks of Commerce Street. Gradually, however, it developed into a rendezvous for the more leisured group of collectors.

Men--and occasionally a woman--who owned many an interesting and valuable volume came to browse and talk. Silent or voluble, enthusiastic or suspiciously conservative, each had in mind some book, of Uncle Moses’ he hoped one day to possess. For it took something more than money and coercion to make this old man give up his treasures. Even when he occasionally fell to this temptation and sold the precious volume, in place of the original he would make a pen-and-ink copy of the book, word for word, so that it was typographically perfect. This would take weeks to do, and only when he needed money badly did he consent to part with the original. I have some of these copies and treasure them as curiosities. Not only months but very often years of tireless perseverance were necessary to make him sell a favorite volume. Equally interesting was that other group which came daily--a group composed of impecunious and peculiarly erratic book lovers, found in book haunts the world over: a poverty-stricken intellectual class, who in filling their minds often forget to provide for their stomachs as well.

All the memories of my childhood centre around the secluded and dusty corners of this shop, where I eavesdropped and prowled to my heart’s content. My uncle, at first annoyed at having a little boy about the place prying into musty papers and books, eventually took delight in showing me rare editions purchased by him at auctions and private sales. As he grew older he became somewhat eccentric, and, despite my extreme youth, insisted upon treating me as a book lover and connoisseur, his own equal. Although he lived to be a very old man, he retained the most marvelous memory I have ever known. He could tell without a moment’s hesitation the date of a book, who the printer was, where it had been found, any physical earmarks it might have, its various vicissitudes, and how it had reached its final destination.

Among the noted collectors who came to match their wits and learning with my uncle was a younger man, Clarence S. Bement, who developed into one of the greatest American book experts. Even at that time he had a wonderful collection, and I well remember his subtle efforts to add to it constantly. He would talk in a firm, low, rather musical voice, obviously toned with persuasion, hoping to make his friend part with some cherished volume he coveted. As I watched Uncle Moses refuse, I saw a curiously adamant and at the same time satisfied expression spread over his features; I noticed, too, the dignity of movement as he gravely took the volume from Bement’s fingers to look at it, with that expressive pride in ownership that verges on madness with many people to whom possession can mean but one thing--books.

Samuel W. Pennypacker, who in later years became governor of Pennsylvania, was another avid book collector and constant habitué of the old Commerce Street bookshop. His hobby was anything he could lay his hands upon from the Franklin press. He also collected all data relating to the early Swedish settlers of Pennsylvania and his German and Dutch ancestors, as well as any material concerning the development of the state. A large man he was, with serious eyes set in a rather square-shaped head. But his voice fascinated me most of all as it boomed about the shelves when he grew excited, and took on an unforgettable Pennsylvania-Dutch twang.

Pennypacker was a fervent admirer of George Washington, and he had once heard of a letter which General Washington wrote from one of the scenes of his childhood, Pennypacker’s Mills. He couldn’t seem to forget this letter, for he was always talking about it, hoping to trace it to its owner and eventually make it his own.

I shall never forget the day Uncle Moses told him he had found and bought this letter. He handed it to Pennypacker with a light of triumphant amusement in his eyes. After reading it, Pennypacker put it down on the table before him and, without raising his eyes, said in a peculiarly exhausted way, “Polock, I must have this letter. You can make any bargain you choose, but I must have it!” Hardly waiting for the other to reply, he rushed down the stairs, to return a few moments later with two books under his arm. My uncle’s blue eyes were but mocking questions as he pushed them aside after glancing at their title pages. They were two valuable books, but not unusually so. Pennypacker had by this time unbuttoned his coat, and I saw him take from an inner pocket a thin, yellow envelope.

“These”--Pennypacker pointed to his two books “and this.” He opened the envelope and gave my uncle its contents. It, too, was a letter from George Washington, yet no sign of emotion swept the old man’s features as he read. But the exchange was made rather quickly, I thought, and it would have been, difficult to decide which bargainer was the more satisfied. I have read both letters many times since. The Pennypacker’s Mills letter was dated September 29, 1777, and addressed: “On public service, to the Honorable John Hancock, President of Congress, Lancaster.” George Washington wrote in part:--

I shall move the Army four or five miles lower down today from where we may reconnoitre and fix upon a proper situation at such distance from the enemy as will enable us to make an attack should we see a proper opening, or stand upon the defensive till we obtain further reinforcements. This was the opinion of a Council of General Officers which I called yesterday.

I congratulate you upon the success of our Arms to the Northward and if some accident does not put them out of their present train, I think we may count upon the total ruin of Burgoyne.

The letter which my uncle received was written four years later from Philadelphia, in 1781, to Abraham Skinner, Commissary General of Prisoners, and was easily the more important, historically, of the two, as General Washington discussed throughout the surrender of Cornwallis and the exchange of prisoners at Yorktown. He instructed General Skinner not to consent to the exchange of Lord Cornwallis under any conditions.

Even I, with but a short experience as a mere onlooker in the collecting game, realized its greater value. After my uncle’s death this Washington letter sold for $925, and it rests to-day as one of the treasures in the Pierpont Morgan collection.

A few years ago I bought back the Pennypacker’s Mills letter for $130 from Governor Pennypacker’s estate. Because of the incident it recalls I would never part with it.

When I was eleven years old I began book collecting on my own. My first purchase was at an auction in the old Henkels’s auction rooms on Chestnut Street. It was an illustrated edition of _Reynard the Fox_, and was knocked down to me for twenty-four dollars. My enthusiasm rather than my financial security swept me into this extravagance, and after the sale I had to go to the auctioneer, Mr. Stan V. Henkels, and confess that I was not exactly solvent. At the same time I explained I was Moses Polock’s nephew, instinctively feeling, I suppose, that such a relationship might account for any untoward action concerning books. I had hardly got the words out of my frightened mouth when Mr. Henkels burst into a fit of laughing which--although I was too young, too scared and self-conscious to realize it at the time--was the beginning of a lifelong friendship between us.

When he ceased laughing, he looked down at me, a sombre little boy with a book under his shaking arm, and said, “I’ve seen it start at an early age, and run in families, but in all my experience this is the very first baby bibliomaniac to come my way!” With this admission he kindly consented to extend credit, and trusted me for further payments, which I was to make weekly from my school allowance. Giving him all the money I possessed, ten dollars, I marched from the auction room, feeling for the first time in my life that swooning yet triumphant, that enervating and at the same time heroic combination of emotions the born bibliomaniac enjoys so intensely with the purchase of each rare book.

Stan V. Henkels--no one dared to leave out the middle initial--was a remarkable man. Even in his young days he resembled an old Southern colonel, the accepted picture we all have, a man of drooping moustache, rather patrician nose, and longish hair which he decorated with a large-brimmed, rusty black hat of the Civil War period. He insisted he was an unreconstructed rebel and was always willing to take on anyone in a verbal battle about the Civil War.

By profession an auctioneer of books, Mr. Henkels was the first person to make the dreary, uninteresting work of auction catalogues into living, fascinating literature, almost as exciting reading as fiction. Previous to this, anyone wanting to find out what was in a collection had little luck when searching through a catalogue, beyond discovering names and dates.