Part 22

1st, One assistant secures the pelvis, in the same manner as in fractures of the lower extremities; while another keeps the leg in a state of perfect extension on the thigh, and the thigh on the pelvis.

2dly, The surgeon, then, standing by the side of the fractured limb, extends along the anterior part of the leg and thigh the roller with holes in it, having previously wet it with vegeto-mineral water, taking care to make the two openings correspond to the lateral parts of the rotula, that, by being thus better adapted to its shape, it may not be thrown into wrinkles.

3dly, He then secures it on the top of the foot, by three circular casts of a roller placed one over the other, three or four inches above its lower end which must next be turned up over the three first casts, and made fast by two other ones. Then, while the compress roller[33] is secured above by an assistant, he passes up along the leg by oblique and reverse turns, according to the inequalities of the limb.

[33] The roller or strip with holes in it, which is extended along the fore part of the limb, serving, in some measure, the purpose of a compress. TRANS.

4thly, Having arrived at the lower part of the knee, he pushes the lower fragment upwards, and makes below it two or three circular turns to secure it. He then gives the roller into the hands of an assistant, and directing him who holds the long compress roller, to draw it forcibly upwards, pushes the integuments of the knee in the same direction, lest, by becoming interposed between the fragments, they might prove an obstacle to their reunion. Passing then the fingers of his left hand through the holes in the compress-roller he places them behind the superior fragment and pushes it forcibly downwards.

5thly, When the reunion of the fragments is exact, without any space intervening, he resumes the roller, and passing it obliquely under the ham, and bringing it up again behind the superior fragment, withdraws his fingers which held this fragment down. In place of his fingers, he then applies two or three tight circular casts, covers the knee with several oblique casts in form of the figure of 8, so as to leave no opening between them, and, then, continues the bandage up along the thigh, securing by it the compress-roller extended along the fore part of the limb.

6thly, When he has arrived at the upper part of the limb, the assistant who holds the compress-roller, drawing it forcibly upwards, doubles down its end over the circular casts. The surgeon next fixing this end by several additional casts, descends again along the thigh, covers the knee by a few more oblique turns, and finishes with the roller on the leg.

33. This first part of the bandage evidently fulfils the third and fourth indications (18). The compression of the roller on the muscles weakening their action and impeding their motions prevents their tendency to draw the superior fragment upwards: while the circular casts passed behind this fragment, acting in opposition to the muscular contractions, prevents it from moving upwards in obedience to them. The long compress-roller, stretched on the fore part of the limb, being first secured below, and then drawn forcibly upwards, presses the casts of the roller against each other, and prevents those that correspond to the thigh from slipping upwards, and thus abandoning the superior fragment, and prevents also those on the leg from slipping down and withdrawing their support from the inferior fragment. As there remains no vacant space between the circular turns, their pressure is uniform throughout: no swelling can consequently supervene (20).

34. But the first and second indications remain still to be fulfilled (18): it is necessary to prevent the separation of the lower fragment, by the extension of the leg on the thigh, and to throw the muscles into a state of relaxation by extending the thigh on the pelvis, and to maintain permanently, by the apparatus, that double position, which the assistant maintains only during the operation.

35. To obtain the first effect different means have been employed; but none answers so well, to extend the limb and retain it immoveably in that state, as a long and strong splint, placed, as Desault did it, subsequently to the application of the first part of the bandage, along the posterior part of the limb. An assistant must hold the end of this splint, while the surgeon secures it in its place by the second roller (31): in this way the extension of the leg is effected.

36. To obtain the extension of the thigh, it is necessary to place on the top of each other, two or three bolsters or little bags filled with chaff, so disposed as to form an inclined plain, considerably elevated towards the heel above the level of the bed, but which, gradually descending to the same level towards the tuberosity of the ischium, forms a supporting basis on which the whole limb may rest in a uniform manner. By this twofold extension of the leg and of the thigh, the lower fragment is kept up immoveably, and the muscles are kept in a state of relaxation.

Hence it follows, that this bandage fulfils extremely well the conditions laid down (18), and that it ought to be preferred to all the others (19 ... 25), which answered the indications only in part.

37. Whatever may be the advantages of this bandage over the others, it must still be acknowledged to have its inconveniences. The rollers become relaxed in a short time; their compression is less active; the muscles, being less confined, contract more readily; hence the necessity of frequently repeating the application of the apparatus, a circumstance which is very troublesome, on account of the roller which composes it, and covers the whole limb. The resistance of it even when it is recently applied, is not always equal to the power of the muscles, whence the most assiduous attention is necessary, to obtain such a consolidation as to leave no trace of the fracture behind. Few persons ever possessed, like Desault, the art of overlooking nothing that might in any way contribute to the success of his treatment: from this, no less than from the excellence of his processes, arose the number of his cures. Let us confirm, by a few examples selected from among a great many, the doctrine here laid down. The following cases were collected by Julian and Bezard.

CASE I. Francis Leclert, of a sanguine temperament, fell on the 7th of October, 1790, on his right knee, and produced a transverse fracture of the rotula. He was not able to rise; he was carried home, where a surgeon, on discovering the nature of his disease, advised him to be taken to the Hotel-Dieu.

He was conveyed thither on the day following, and, in the interval, a considerable swelling had occurred around the joint. The usual bandage was employed; the pains ceased immediately after its application; a copious blood-letting was directed, and a low diet was prescribed.

The whole apparatus was wet with vegeto-mineral water, two or three times a day. On the next day some light food was allowed, and the quantity increased by degrees, till in a short time the patient returned to his usual regimen. Eighth day, the swelling being almost gone, the bandage had become relaxed it was therefore reapplied. Every day the inclined plain formed by the bolsters was carefully examined, and put in order again as often as it became deranged.

Fifteenth day, a new application of the apparatus: twentieth day, an evacuation in consequence of a bilious disposition. Nothing particular occurred from this time till the completion of the cure, which took place on the sixty-seventh day after the accident: no depression existed at the place of the fracture: the motions were perfectly free; these were aided, by daily exercising the knee joint for some time.

CASE II. Vincent Grenier, aged thirty-eight, making a false step, fell on the rotula, and fractured it, on the 6th of June, 1791: he was brought to the Hotel-Dieu, where Desault demonstrated to his pupils, by the usual signs the existence of the disease: a considerable swelling had already taken place. The bandage formerly described was applied: the same precaution as in the preceding case; apparatus examined every day; renewed as often as relaxed; extension maintained with great exactness. On the forty-fifth day, the consolidation was nearly effected; on the fifty-second it was complete, the joint was exercised for some time, and on the seventy-seventh day the cure being in all respects complete, the patient was discharged.

MEMOIR XIV.

ON THE FORMATION OF FOREIGN BODIES IN THE JOINT OF THE KNEE.

1. The history of foreign bodies divides itself naturally into two great sections; the one includes those that are introduced from without; the other such as are formed within our own systems. This latter section may be again divided into two classes; to the first class belong bodies altogether inorganic, such as the different kinds of stones; to the second, those which are truly organic, and become foreign only by being situated in places where they impede the functions, such as cartilaginous or bony productions, existing accidentally within the joints.

On the subject of the latter class, art is much more deficient than she is with regard to the former. Let us endeavour to assist her a little, by giving a sketch of the opinions and practice of Desault with respect to these productions.

2. Before his time, the surgery of France appears to have contained scarcely a record of this affection. Described only in some ancient works, such as the writings of Pare, it had been forgotten by the moderns, when numerous instances of it were suddenly met with by English and German surgeons, and soon afterwards by Desault, who illustrated and confirmed the practice of his predecessors in it, and even added something of his own.

3. All the joints may become the seat of these concretions; Haller found many of them in that of the lower jaw; Bell mentions, as a very rare occurrence, their existence at the junction of the foot with the leg. Some authors have met with them in the wrist; but none are more common, or merit more particular attention, than those that exist in the joint of the knee. To these alone shall the following observations be confined, because these alone have fallen under the notice of Desault.

§ II.

OF THE VARIETIES.

4. Concretions of the joints do not always assume the same aspect. They vary greatly as to number, size, figure, structure, &c. In general, these bodies exist singly; sometimes, however, two of them are found in the same joint, and then they may be extracted either at the same time, or in succession, as was once done by Desault. Some English surgeons have also met with two concretions, and Morgagni has found even twenty-five, in the same joint.

5. They vary also in size. The largest ever met with by Desault, was fourteen lines in its longest, and ten in its shortest diameter. Six lines diameter in every direction, was the measure of the smallest one that occurred in his practice.

6. Their figure is sometimes lenticular and smooth on both sides, sometimes unequal, rough in one part, even in another, concave on one side, convex on the opposite, sometimes marked around the circumference and sometimes not with reddish points, and having occasionally a stem of a cellular texture and of some length, as may be seen in a paper by Theden. They usually consist of a single mass, but are in some cases divided into several lobules united by a kind of ligaments, as in the fourth case related in the Journal of Surgery. Though most frequently detached and floating in the interior of the joint, they have yet been found adhering by means of small portions of cellular substance, loose and capable of being stretched, or tight, hard, and even of a ligamentous nature.

7. If, from the external figure, we pass to the structure of these bodies, we will find them existing in three different states. Sometimes purely cartilaginous, sometimes completely bony, they at other times partake of both these states, in which case a bony nucleus is covered with a cartilaginous crust. Out of five cases, recorded by Desault, three are of the first, and two of the third kind. Many authors have met with the second kind, particularly Morgagni, who has even found in the same joint, some bodies of a bony and others of a cartilaginous nature. Hence it appears, that this variety of structure is to be attributed to the longer or shorter standing of the disease, that every concretion must pass successively through these three states, and that there is a great analogy between the formation of such bodies and natural ossification.

8. If we examine a body of the third kind cut in two through the middle, we will find it red and vascular in the centre, like an epiphysis, even when it is floating in the joint perfectly loose and free from adhesion.

9. Bell, in his treatise on surgery, speaks of a kind of tumour, at first soft, membranous, and adhering to the internal surface of the capsule, but which, according to him, may become afterwards hard and solid, and be detached so as to float loose in the joint. But are not these tumours different in their nature from those destined to be converted into bone? Do they, in fact, ever undergo the changes mentioned by Bell? Desault having never met with any of them, was unable to offer an opinion on the subject. In the mean time, an observation made by Monro, may serve to throw some light on the question: he once saw, in one of these productions, a cellular nucleus surrounded by a covering of bone.

10. Though usually simple and free from complication, this affection may, according to some authors, give rise occasionally to a dropsy in the joint. Pare is the first who has made mention of this: he found one of these bodies in a patient’s knee, into which he had made an incision for the purpose of drawing off a collection of water. Simson, on extracting a similar body, gave vent to four ounces of water. But, as on the one hand, a dropsy of a joint oftentimes exists without these foreign bodies; so, on the other, these bodies are almost always found disconnected from dropsy. Nor is there any affinity between the acknowledged causes of an accumulation of synovia, and the presence of these bodies; so that when the two diseases do exist together, it is altogether probable, that they are independent of each other.

§ III.

OF THE CAUSES.

11. The formation of articular concretions succeeds frequently to blows or falls received on the joint, in which case, a swelling more or less considerable in the surrounding soft parts, showing itself from the first, and remaining for some time, at length allows the foreign body to be perceived, and does not, in general, disappear during the continuance of the body in the part.

12. Sometimes no external injury contributes to the formation of the body, and then, a spontaneous swelling precedes its detection, as Desault observed in two patients, where nothing was known to have concurred in the production of the disease. Constant rest increases this swelling, while exercise and a temperate mode of life diminish it.

13. But what can be the immediate cause of these tumours? Are they, as some allege, an aggregation or crystallization of particles of matter conveyed into the interior of the joint by the synovia, in the same manner as the rudiments of a stone are conveyed into the bladder by the urine? Their organic appearance and the vessels that pervade them, are unfavourable to such an opinion. Can they be, agreeably to the conjecture of Theden, articular glands bruised by means of strokes or falls? Or are they, as some authors will have it, portions of the cartilage of the joint, detached by the same causes? How then will their spontaneous formation be explained?

But why trouble ourselves about the cause, provided we can remedy the effects? Nature conceals from us the means, and discloses to us nothing but the results. Theories are fluctuating; but experience is still the same: let us search, then, by an attention to facts, for that which we cannot learn from first principles.

§ IV.

OF THE SIGNS.

14. The phenomena which announce the presence of foreign bodies in the joint of the knee, are sometimes clothed in a character of such evidence, that they cannot be mistaken; at other times, the nature of the disease eludes the most accurate researches: the cause of this variety may be easily perceived.

As the joint presents different depressions and eminences, and as the bodies, being usually loose and detached, may travel through its whole extent, they produce different effects, according to the particular situations which they occupy. If lodged in a depression, they are not compressed, and cannot, of course, give rise to any troublesome affection. If they bear on an eminence, such as the condyls, or the posterior part of the rotula, they are forcibly compressed, and must derange, in some measure, the functions of the joint. Hence the precise nature of the affection cannot be at all times derived from the state of the symptoms.

15. Sometimes the patient can stand and walk with perfect freedom and ease, while, at other times, a sudden pain seizing him, obliges him to sit down, or even causes him to fall, if there be nothing at hand to support him. This pain subsists for a longer or shorter time. One motion produces it, and sometimes another, made in an opposite direction, removes it. But in common it is of some continuance, and then the patient is obliged to keep his bed.

16. If the state of the joint be examined, it will be found more or less swollen, when the pain is very acute. When the pain ceases, the swelling in part disappears. It is never sufficient to prevent the fingers, when drawn along the external surface of the joint, from discovering the presence of the foreign body, when it forms a protuberance under the integuments. It is then found sometimes above the rotula, by the side of the tendon of the extensor muscles, and that is the place where it usually produces least pain; at other times, it is lower down, in front of the condyls, and by the side of the rotula. It is occasionally found immediately behind the tendon of the extensor muscles; in this case so acute is the pain, that the patient is generally unable to stand. But it is when it is situated behind the rotula, near to the projecting ridge which runs across its posterior surface, that it gives rise to the most serious affections.

17. The body passes from one place to another, on the least motion, and sometimes, as Bell observes, the patient, on changing his position during sleep, is awakened by severe pain, in consequence of the foreign body being moved by this change. It happens, in certain cases, that it disappears, and lies concealed for some time, in the back part of the joint. During this period the joint performs all its functions with freedom and ease. Desault made this remark, in the case of a captain of dragoons, from whom, for the first time in his practice, he extracted one of these bodies, and who, for six months previously, had been able to perform all the motions of the joint freely, without pain. This person, experiencing no uneasiness, considered himself perfectly cured, when the body suddenly reappeared, in consequence of a hasty extension of the leg.

18. If the body, when projecting under the integuments, be gently compressed, it yields to the pressure, changes its situation, and, according to the impression it has received, moves either to the internal or the external side of the joint, or reciprocally from one side to the other, passing also behind the rotula, behind the inferior ligament, or sometimes behind the tendon of the extensor muscles. In these alternate displacements, it may in some cases be turned round, in such a manner that its anterior surface will take the place of its posterior one, and then resume its primitive situation. Desault met with an instance, in which the patient himself was in the habit of turning the body round in this manner.

19. Bell, in conformity to the distinction of articular concretions into cellular and solid, attributes to each division its peculiar signs. In the first case, the pains, being rather obtuse than sharp, are constant; in the second, they are extremely acute, but disappear and return at intervals. Supposing the division to be a real one, cases of the last description certainly occur much more frequently than those of the first.

§ V.

OF THE TREATMENT.

20. From what has been said it follows, 1st, that these cartilages floating through the joints, do mischief mechanically (14), by coming into contact with the articular surfaces: 2dly, that to obviate this mischief, it is necessary either to prevent their contact, by fixing the bodies in a spacious part of the joint, and thus doing constantly what nature does on certain occasions, or to extract them through an opening made into the articular cavity.

21. Hence, art can have recourse to but two methods of cure, all hope of discussing these tumours by external applications being, as Bell observes, entirely extinguished.

22. The first method was proposed by Middleton and Gooch, who having brought the foreign body into a situation where it produced no pain, endeavoured to confine it there a length of time sufficient to make it form adhesions with the corresponding part of the capsule. As we are not informed of the result of the experiments of these two physicians, we are left to our own conjectures on the subject.

23. Are these foreign bodies capable of forming adhesions? Supposing they are, will the internal surface of the capsule attach itself to them at the pleasure of the surgeon? Even admitting the existence of both these conditions, by what means can the bodies be kept stationary for a length of time sufficient for the formation of these adhesions? Will they not be displaced by the slightest motion? Besides, experience seems to be unfavourable to the expedient. I have already said (17) that, in a certain case, the foreign body disappeared for six months, remaining, no doubt, during that whole time, in the same place: but, if it could not, on that occasion, form adhesions, if a motion was sufficient to produce its reappearance, can we expect that art will be more fortunate in her attempts?

24. But, even admitting that the foreign body does form these adhesions with the capsule, if it should increase in size in the part of the joint which it occupies, becoming in a short time disproportioned to its extent, it will impede motion as before, and produce, by degrees, nearly the same affections.

25. From these considerations it follows, that the only expedient which can promise a radical cure is, the extraction of the foreign body. In the performance of this extraction, an incision must first be made through the integuments and the capsule.

26. This operation, simple and easy in itself, has given rise to apprehensions as to its consequences, which have long prevented practitioners from undertaking it.

It was in former times a maxim in surgery, that wounds of the joints are, if not mortal, at least extremely dangerous, in consequence of their admitting air into contact with the articulating surfaces. But observation has demonstrated the fallacy of this doctrine, and Desault in particular, has thrown great light on the subject, as I have frequently had occasion to mention in the course of this work: so that, at the present day, it is clearly ascertained, that, if judiciously treated, these wounds are seldom productive of serious consequences.